Red Dead Redemption 2: Why RDR2 Online is dead on arrival

Pratyay
RDR Online is seeing players leave in droves
RDR Online is seeing players leave in droves

The single player story part of Red Dead Redemption is one of the most incredible single player experiences you can play this generation. The main story last about 45 to 50 hours as we follow Arthur Morgan during his journey through America in the dying days of the Wild West.

I won't spoil anything about the main story in this article because what we're going to do is look at Red Dead Online which is still in it's 'Beta' phase even though it already offers microtransactions.

So far, Red Dead Online has not done well and has lost a lot of players since launch. It's isn't helping that GTA online is popular as ever. Let's take a look at why Red Dead online is failing:


Not enough content

RDR Online needs more content
RDR Online needs more content

The biggest problem facing Red Dead Online right now is that there just isn't enough content to keep players engaged. To give credit where it's due, the way Rockstar integrated the story missions in RDR Online was brilliantly done but how many times can you re-play those missions.

We are also still waiting side activities like Poker to be added to Red Dead Online.


Pay to win mechanics

RDR Online is pay to win
RDR Online is pay to win

While you can argue that GTA V is also pay to win, Red Dead Online released in 2018 and players are not anywhere near as accepting of pay to win mechanics now as they were back when GTA Online released.

Red Dead Online is a total grind and rewards are paltry compared to how much items cost. Let's put it this way, the amount of money you make from activities is okay if you look at how things were priced back then but everything you but in the game are priced more akin to prices now. This was obviously done to encourage players to buy gold bars.

Instead of grinding for the higher level weapons, players can just buy the best weapon immediately with gold bars.

The Battle Royale mode is a disaster

RDR Online needs a lot of work
RDR Online needs a lot of work

The introduced a 32-player battle royale mode in Red Dead Online after launch and it's a total disaster. I won't even comment on the fact that it has auto-aim but the circle also closes in a predictable way. The players also tend to veer to the center of the map where weapons are.

What can I say? i=It's just not fun to play.


Nerfing the best ways to make money

Hunting and fishing are now nerfed
Hunting and fishing are now nerfed

With Rockstar Games rebalancing Read Dead Online in recent updates, they've nerfed the best ways for players to earn in freeroam - hunting and fishing. This was how I was making most of my money before Rockstar's nerf and their explanation for it was ludicrous.


GTA Online

GTA Online is as popular as ever
GTA Online is as popular as ever

When GTA Online came out, not only were their less online persistent gaming experiences in the market, it also didn't have to compete with itself.

It's been pretty clear over the last couple of months that a lot of frustrated Red Dead Online players are going back to GTA Online.

Quick Links

App download animated image Get the free App now