Write & Earn
Favorites Edit

ISL 2017, Match 11: FC Pune City vs Mumbai City FC, Player Ratings

Rating and slating the individual performances from the Maharashtra derby

Feature 30 Nov 2017, 01:38 IST

The first Maharashtra derby of the ISL 2017 season went right down to the wire as FC Pune City came back from a goal down to beat rivals Mumbai City FC, courtesy a last-minute winner from their talisman Emiliano Alfaro.

Ranko Popovic's men started the game on the back foot and conceded an early goal when Balwant Singh found the back of the net with a sensational strike from outside the area on the 15th minute.

The Stallions slowly started finding their feet and continued to dominate possession, heading into the halftime break as the stronger side. Pune were finally rewarded when Raju Gaikwad brought down Diego Carlos in the 71st minute and Alfaro converted from the spot with ease to level things up.

It was Alfaro again who sent the Balewadi Stadium into an explosion of cheers as he got on to the end of a ball from Diego to tap in a 93rd-minute winner and help Pune gain bragging rights over their arch-rivals. Here, we take a look at how the players from both sides were rated on the night.

FC Pune City

Alfaro wason top form against Mumbai. (Photo: ISL)
Alfaro was on top form against Mumbai. (Photo: ISL)

Kamaljit Singh - 5/10

The Pune City shot-stopper did not produce a commanding performance between the sticks and looked a bit shaky on a few instances. However, he could do nothing about the goal and did not receive any favours from his defenders while conceding the same.

Baljit Sahni - 6/10

Sahni did well whenever he came up against the Mumbai City attack and showed good composure on the ball. The defender lived up to his manager's flattering words about him before the game and restricted Abhinas Ruidas to his own half on many occasions.

Rafael Lopez - 6/10

Lopez carried out his duties at the back and slowly settled in as the game progressed with Pune taking control of the situation. Apart from the goal, the opposition attackers could not pose any challenging threat whatsoever for the defender.

Gurtej Singh - 6/10

Gurtej also did not face a lot of difficulty while keeping the Mumbai attackers on bay. He enjoyed playing the ball forward on a few occasions and did well to keep Everton Santos quiet.

Lalchhuanmawia Fanai - 6/10

Fanai got forward on a few instances and helped his team, both in offense and while defending. He also forced Sanju Pradhan to track back and hardly gave the winger any time on the ball.

Marcos Tebar - 5/10

A disappointing night for Tebar was completed when he was taken off in the 62nd minute after he failed to exert any control in the game despite being in very decent form lately.

Rohit Kumar - 6/10

The midfielder came up against a strong Mumbai midfield that was never shy of putting in challenges and closing down players at will. However, he covered a lot of ground and worked hard in midfield especially when Pune didn't have the ball.

Marcelinho - 7/10

The Brazilian continued his good form for the Stallions and came close to scoring on a few occasions but was denied only by Amrinder Singh's heroics. Marcelinho seems to have established a quality relationship with Alfaro, a partnership that could work wonders for the club.

Diego Carlos - 7/10

A bit wasteful on the night but Carlos stayed on and initiated the comeback by winning a penalty and providing the assist to Alfaro for the winner.

Issac Vanmalsawma - 6/10

The 20-year-old showed glimpses of promise while going forward in the first half but eventually faded off before being taken off in the 77th minute as Pune pushed for the winner.

Emiliano Alfaro - 9/10

The Uruguayan continued his fine goal-scoring form from the game against ATK and followed up with a brace in his first ever Maha derby. Alfaro has been the best striker in the league so far without the shadow of a doubt.


Kean Lewis - 6/10

The winger looked lively after coming on and enjoyed linking up with Marcelinho and Alfaro

Jonatan Lucca - 5/10

Lucca had a shot saved by Amrinder after coming on in the 77th minute but failed to make any headlines.

Adil Khan - N/A

Came on in the 90th minute

Page 1 of 2 Next
Fetching more content...