5 chilling details about Jennifer Lancaster, Sidney, and Monique's disappearance 

The disappearance of Jennifer Lancaster and her two infant daughters, Sidney and Monique, from Topeka, Kansas, has been a mystery for more than two decades. On May 12, 2000, Jennifer left her apartment with her daughters, informing her mother that she was going to get laundry done. She failed to return.

The next day, her car was discovered abandoned, stripped of all personal items, including the car seats for the children. No sign of Jennifer or her daughters has materialized since then. The case is still open and has some noteworthy details.

Many of these details are covered in the Crime Junkie podcast episode, MISSING: Jennifer, Sidney, and Monique, which aired on their website on June 23, 2025.

---

Five particular details surrounding Jennifer Lancaster, Sidney, and Monique's disappearance

1) Jennifer Lancaster left home for laundry despite having a washer and dryer

As per the Crime Junkie podcast, on the evening of May 12, 2000, Jennifer Lancaster informed her mother, Vicki, that she going to get laundry done. She had a clear trash bag containing baby clothes and quilts.

This behavior, her mother said, was nonsensical and uncharacteristic of Jennifer since their family apartment was furnished with a washer and dryer.

Media coverage (Representative photo by Pexels )

---

2) The abandoned car was left empty

As per Missing Leads, Jennifer Lancaster's 1994 Jeep Cherokee was discovered abandoned two days after she went missing. The vehicle had been parked at an apartment complex in Topeka's southeast section. Family members and investigators reported that the personal belongings, including the car keys and both children's car seats, were taken from the vehicle.

As per Crime Junkie podcast, the vehicle was described as unusually clean, which struck Jennifer’s family as odd, given that she was a mother of two young children. This detail suggested that someone had intentionally cleared out the car after Jennifer disappeared.

---

3) Jennifer’s phone and paycheck were left behind

As per Crime Junkie podcast, after Jennifer Lancaster went missing, her mother discovered that Jennifer’s cell phone was left at home. Jennifer's phone was on her mother's plan, and she hadn't made any calls on it during the previous week before she'd gone missing.

Crime scene (Representative photo by Pexels )

Also, Jennifer left her final paycheck at the bar where she worked and took no credit cards or large amounts of cash with her. These details cast suspicion on the theory that Jennifer voluntarily left home since she did not pack crucial items she would require to begin a new life.

---

4) Additional personal items are missing in the household

Jennifer's mother reported that she noticed how many of Jennifer's personal items were missing from the house, other than the baby clothes and quilts she took with her on May 12, 2000.

This caused rumors to spread that Jennifer Lancaster might have been taking things out of the house over time as she was preparing to leave, or that other people removed the items since she vanished. However, there has been no confirmation for either case, and the motive for the missing property is still unclear.

---

5) No activity or confirmed sightings since the disappearance

As per the Crime Junkie podcast, despite widespread searches and media coverage, Jennifer Lancaster, Sidney, and Monique have not been officially sighted since the evening of their disappearance. Jennifer's bank accounts, social security number, and other documents have remained inactive since May 2000.

---

For more details, listen to the podcast.