ISL 2017: Rating the 5 top foreign signings this season

Alfaro was NorthEast United's top scorer in ISL 2016
Alfaro was NorthEast United's top scorer in ISL 2016

With the conclusion of the Indian Super League domestic draft last Sunday, clubs have now turned their attention to the foreign transfer market. As things stand, a total of 17 players has been signed by the ten ISL franchises, with new entrants Bengaluru FC making the most number of signings so far with five.

As we approach the new ISL season that kick starts mid-November, we will witness a raft of overseas arrivals in Indian football. With the transfer season in full swing, let us take a look at the five best transfers made by ISL clubs over the summer.

To make the rating procedure more objective, we had listed five criteria based on which the new foreign signings were ranked. The criteria are:

Career span: The more experienced a player is, the more he can add to a particular team both on and off the pitch and help develop young players in the squad. In general, the older a player, the more experienced he is.

Age: The correlation between age and performance has been debated, but in general, football players are considered to be past their peak when they cross 30. Therefore, signing a player less than 30 years of age makes for a fitter, younger squad primed to play an extended ISL season.

Experience in Asia: Asian football wildly differs from its European or South American counterparts. Therefore, a player with prior experience of Asian football stands to be more successful in Indian football.

Experience in India: This is the most vital part because Indian football is not the same as football in other parts of the world. A player with two years of experience in India is generally expected to perform better than a complete newcomer.

Trophies won: Being part of a winning team is an achievement in itself, bringing that winning mentality to ISL dressing rooms plays a big part in a team's success.

The aim is to be as objective as possible but in football, being a dynamic game, there will be anomalies. Here is our list of the top five foreign signings by ISL clubs this season.

#5 Emiliano Alfaro

The Uruguayan striker is a hugely experienced campaigner and top scored last season for NorthEast United in the ISL. Having learnt his craft under the tutelage of Diego Simeone at San Lorenzo, Alfaro has played around the world and in India as well. He also featured alongside Luis Suarez and Edinson Cavani for the "Golden Generation" Uruguay team at the turn of this decade.

Alfaro is a poacher inside the box and his signing by FC Pune City looks shrewder by the day. That he is only 29 suggests that the Stallions have pulled off a coup with Alfaro's capture.

#4 Erik Paartalu

Erik Paartalu has had a long career
Erik Paartalu has had a long career

Bengaluru FC's new signing surprisingly makes this list despite not having played in India yet. The Australian has spent most of his career playing in his homeland and ventured out to the West only once when he went to Scotland in the early part of his career before returning to Asia-Oceania.

Paartalu is highly experienced and has won the A-League title with Brisbane Roar. His title-winning pedigree will be an added asset to Bengaluru apart from his nous on the pitch as a defensive midfielder.

#3 Lucian Goian

Lucian Goian was named the the ISL Team of the Season in 2016
Lucian Goian was named the ISL Team of the Season in 2016

The imposing centre-back was the best defender in the ISL last season. Goian led his Mumbai City side to the semi-finals of the ISL for the first time in 2016 and is heavily tipped to repeat the trick next season as well. The 34-year-old is hugely experienced and has won five trophies in a career that has been spent mostly in his native Romania.

Mumbai City re-signed Goian earlier this week to signal their intentions for the upcoming season. With his arrival, Mumbai City and their head coach Alexandre Guimaraes have their defence sorted.

#2 Iain Hume

Iain Hume is an ISL legend
Iain Hume is an ISL legend

The shaven-headed Canadian has taken the ISL by storm ever since he first set foot on an Indian pitch back in 2014. Hume is the all-time top goalscorer in the history of the ISL with 23 strikes to his name and has played in two finals, winning the title last year with ATK.

Hume is now back at Kerala Blasters, but the Canada international is a year older now and opposing defences a year wiser. The 33-year-old will be expected to score at will, but it will not be easy. That said, the mere mention of Hume is still a threat to ISL defences.

#1 John Johnson

John Johnson has been a loyal Bengaluru FC servant
John Johnson has been a loyal Bengaluru FC servant

The former Middlesbrough defender has been with Bengaluru FC since the club's establishment in 2013 and has won silverware in every season with the Blues. Johnson is a crowd favourite among the Bengaluru faithful and his contract renewal recently was warmly received by the club's fans.

Johnson's four-year experience of Indian football and his trophy haul in the country speaks volumes of him and his team, Bengaluru FC's rise. That the Blues managed to retain him for the upcoming season makes them one of the challengers for the title.

Quick Links