5 chilling details about Jake and Kelley Branam’s murder

Marine police unit of the Bursa Police Department - Source: Getty
Jake Branam was the 27-year-old skipper of the 47-foot charter boat Joe Cool (Image via Getty)

Kelley Branam and her husband, charter-boat skipper Jake Branam, accepted two last-minute passengers for what was supposed to be a routine run from Miami to Bimini on September 22, 2007. Within 24 hours, the 47-foot charter boat, Joe Cool, was found adrift near Cuba, its crew missing, and the deck spattered with blood.

Ad

Investigators soon concluded that Kelley Branam, Jake, and crewmates Scott Gamble and Samuel Kairy had been murdered at sea, and their bodies cast overboard. Viewers can retrace the tragedy when Fatal Destination airs The Ghost Ship on Investigation Discovery on Tuesday, July 1, 2025, at 10 pm ET/PT.

As per the ABC News report dated September 26, 2007, relatives called the disappearance “a bad dream,” unaware that fugitive Kirby Logan Archer and teen companion Guillermo Zarabozo had already spun a false tale of Cuban pirates.

Ad

5 key details about the Jake and Kelley Branam murders, explored

Ad

1) The unexplained southward turn sealed Kelley Branam’s fate

Coast-Guard radar showed the Joe Cool veering sharply south, not east toward the Bahamas, less than two hours after leaving port. Prosecutors later argued that Archer, a Walmart manager wanted for stealing $92,000, drew a handgun and forced Kelley Branam, her husband, and the two crewmen to kneel before opening fire, all to reach Cuba’s non-extradition haven.

As per a CBS News report dated October 10, 2007, officials noted the $4,000 cash charter and sudden course change as the first red flags.

Ad

2) Forensic clues on deck contradicted the “pirate” story

Four spent 9 mm shell casings and multiple blood pools matched the missing crew, while credit cards, electronics, and $70,000 in gear were untouched. As per the FBI's “Murder on the High Seas” story dated February 26, 2009, FBI Special Agent Herbert “Skip” Hogberg talked about the same.

“Pirates would have taken all of that,” the agent said.

The untouched valuables convinced agents that Kelley Branam and the others had been targeted in a planned hijacking, not by random bandits.

Ad

3) Archer’s hidden criminal past gave the crime its motive

Before meeting Kelley Branam, Archer had fled Arkansas's child molestation and theft probes. Investigators found emails outlining his plan to reroute the charter to Cuba for refuge.

According to the FBI press release dated May 6, 2009, Assistant U.S. Attorney Karen Gilbert praised agents who recreated a crime scene in the middle of the ocean, enabling murder indictments without recovering remains.


4) A jailhouse confession deepened the case against Zarabozo

Ad

While awaiting trial, Zarabozo allegedly told a cellmate that Archer shot the captain, Kelley, and the others after they refused to head south. As per a CBS News report dated December 20, 2007, defense lawyer Anthony Natale provided updates on the incident.

“We are looking into the government’s allegations and will respond appropriately in court or in our pleadings,” he stated.

Prosecutors used the account to illustrate how both men tried to hide their roles in Kelley's murder.

Ad

5) Convictions without bodies brought rare maritime justice

Ad

Despite never locating Kelley's remains, circumstantial proof, ballistics, DNA, and GPS trails led Archer to plead guilty in July 2008. He accepted five consecutive life terms, avoiding a possible death sentence.

Zarabozo’s first jury hung, but a 2009 retrial delivered five life sentences plus 85 years. The FBI summary notes that Archer’s plea underscored the overwhelming evidence tying him to Kelley's death.

Fatal Destination’s upcoming broadcast revisits how investigators pieced together each chilling detail.

Ad

Stay tuned for more updates.

Quick Links

Edited by Meenakshi Ajith
Sportskeeda logo
Close menu
WWE
WWE
NBA
NBA
NFL
NFL
MMA
MMA
Tennis
Tennis
NHL
NHL
Golf
Golf
MLB
MLB
Soccer
Soccer
F1
F1
WNBA
WNBA
More
More
bell-icon Manage notifications