#8 Tom Cleverly
Tom Cleverly was supposed to be the next Paul Scholes, and under the leadership of Sir Alex Ferguson, he had a brilliant start to his career. He promptly became a regular for England as well, but his brilliant start to the season was cut short with injury.
After Sir Alex left, he had a drop in form like any other player in a United shirt under David Moyes. He was often used as a scapegoat for the 20-time champions' poor showings, and was sent on loan by Louis van Gaal.
After a relatively successful spell at Aston Villa, he was allowed to leave for Everton. But he struggled to get into the Everton team and is now on loan to Watford.
A decent professional, but ultimately nothing like Paul Scholes. It is quite surprising that he was actually rated highly, as none of his attributes made him stand out.