Lynley season 1 episode 2 ending explained: Who killed Gemma?

Lynley season 1, episode 2 continued the investigations of Detective Inspector Thomas Lynley and Detective Sergeant Barbara Havers as they solved intricate murder cases in England. The most recent episode delves into Gemma Hastings' murder, whose vanishing act had captivated the investigator's attention.

Disclaimer: The following article contains spoilers for the show. Reader's discretion is advised.

DS Barbara Havers had covertly pursued the investigation after DI Lynley was taken off the case for covering her error, and she had found horrifying information regarding Gemma's link with a ten-year-old boy's murder. Gemma was seen visiting the grave of the boy, leaving a sorry note. Eventually, viewers are informed that her ex-boyfriend, Gareth, was actually Jason Parry, a man who had been jailed for stabbing the boy in the past.

The case turned sinister when it was discovered that Fraser, Gemma's roommate, had been blackmailing Gareth after discovering his true identity. Lynley season 1 episode 2 concludes in a flashback showcasing a physical altercation, in which Fraser unintentionally murdered Gemma by hitting her on the head with a hammer. The episode delved into themes of guilt, betrayal, and desperation, leaving viewers struggling with the tragic irony of unintended actions.

---

Why did Gemma visit Luke Kneighton's grave in Lynley season 1 episode 2?

A still from the episode (Image via BritBox)

In the course of Lynley season 1 episode 2, Gemma Hastings's repeated visits to ten-year-old Luke Kneighton's gravesite remained an unsettling mystery. It was first presumed that Gemma acted out of pity or felt some kind of guilt related to the deceased child.

The detectives discovered the messages left by Gemma in apology, signed with a "G," which suggested a personal relationship. These innocuous-looking visits were meant as gestures of atonement, rather than a sinister engagement.

The fact that Gemma was involved with Jason Parry, a man with a violent record and concealed identity, painted a more complex picture. Her visits suggested that she was trying to make amends for secrets she held close, perhaps when she realized her ex-boyfriend's past offense.

The subplot kept audiences questioning whether Gemma was a victim of circumstance or a criminal covering up her own sins, creating a sense of moral nuance that blurred straightforward judgments of guilt and innocence.

---

How did the blackmail spiral into murder in Lynley season 1 episode 2?

A still from the episode (Image via BritBox)

A spine-tingling aspect of Lynley season 1 episode 2 was the gradual breakdown of a blackmail plot that escalated into fatal violence. Fraser, Gemma's unobtrusive flatmate, at first seemed to be just a peripheral figure, but turned out to be the blackmailer of Jason Parry, otherwise known as Gareth.

Fraser's motive was complex due to his financial need born of a toxic relationship and the weight of a recently released prison partner. His blackmail of Gareth for $200,000 brought a note of inevitable tragedy to the story, as the audience was made to expect a dramatic showdown.

The conclusion of this subplot came when Gemma was forced to confront Fraser to defend Gareth, and was accidentally hit in the head by him in their struggle. The abrupt turn from psychological abuse to physical violence revealed the true nature of events. This flashback clearly shows that Fraser's motives were the outcome of sheer desperation and not meticulous planning.

---

What was DS Barbara Havers' role in Lynley season 1 episode 2?

The outcome of Gemma Hastings's case in Lynley season 1 episode 2 relied heavily on DS Barbara Havers's refusal to drop the investigation with DI Lynley, even after he was officially taken off the case. Her conscience for not keeping an eye on suspect Leo, coupled with the emotional pressure of having to attend to her ailing father, placed her on a tangent of investigation that went against procedure.

This subplot elevated the tension between institutional bureaucracy and individual moral responsibility. Lynley's relentless drive resulted in uncovering pivotal evidence, Fraser's email, and eventually his lethal fight with Gemma, exposing the concealed truth. The story presented an underlying question of whether the case could have been solved without Havers's secret work with Lynel.

It points to the underlying theme of individual responsibility and the pitfalls of silence in the presence of misdeed. The episode highlights the individual price paid for doing the right thing and how having the right partner is absolutely crucial for solving a crime mystery.

---

Lynley season 1 episode 2 is available to stream on BritBox.