Tara Gillon’s murder on The Real Murders on Elm Street season 2 episode 2: A detailed case overview

The Real Murders on Elm Street season 2 turns to Middleborough, Massachusetts, in episode 2, Trailing a Killer. The episode revisits the New Year’s Eve killing of 20-year-old Tara Gillon and the fast-moving probe that followed. The episode frames a key clue from the scene as a single missing shoe and builds the timeline around it.

Trailing a Killer places Tara’s father’s return at about 11 pm on December 31, 1996, when he found her inside the living room with fatal injuries. The series then tracks how police worked footprints outside the house, canvassed nearby parties, and focused on an 18-year-old named Ryan Burgess.

---

The Real Murders on Elm Street season 2 episode 2 case overview

The program sets the scene at 278 Old Center Street, a two-story home where Tara was visiting for the holidays. A ransacked interior, a suspect running out a back door, and those shoe impressions move the story from shock to pursuit. The missing right shoe becomes a narrative thread in the episode, signaling how a small item can mark a path through the night.

The Real Murders on Elm Street season 2 (Image via YouTube/@InvestigationDiscovery)

As shown on screen, the police follow the prints toward Ash Street and ask questions at local gatherings. A name surfaces. So does talk of someone leaving a party early after an argument. The hour then cuts between interviews and staged moments that mark each step.

---

Investigation details in The Real Murders on Elm Street season 2

Details presented in the court record show the next phase. Officers reportedly found visible blood on pants, scratches on arms, and Puma sneakers that matched prints at the scene.

Assistant District Attorney Frank Gaziano later said the suspect confessed to breaking in, choking her, stabbing Tara more than 20 times, and then raping her after the killing. According to SouthCoast Today, police also searched for a thin steak knife that the suspect allegedly said he discarded.

The episode reflects that record by showing the sequence from entry to flight, then the follow-up at an Elm Street address where the teen had been staying. Interviews recall alcohol use earlier in the night, a quick departure from a party, and the claim that he walked home.

The defense requested a psychiatric evaluation, which the court did not grant, and contemporaneous interviews reflected shock at the arrest, as reported by SouthCoast Today.

---

Trial and appeals tied to The Real Murders on Elm Street season 2

A Plymouth County jury convicted Ryan Burgess in January 1998, and the judge imposed life without parole. The defense later sought a new trial, arguing issues with seized clothing, statements to police, and intoxication.

The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court upheld the convictions, calling the crime brutal and rejecting each claim. SouthCoast Today reported that the court cited the defendant’s actions after the killing, including leaving the scene and disposing of the knife, as evidence of intent and awareness.

The Real Murders on Elm Street season 2 (Image via YouTube/@InvestigationDiscovery)

The program aligns its final act with that outcome. It closes the loop from the missing shoe to footprints, from interviews to forensic matches, then to a verdict that still stands. Where specific counts are concerned, first-degree murder and armed home invasion remain on the books.

---

New episodes of The Real Murders on Elm Street season 2 air on Investigation Discovery. Episode 2, Trailing a Killer, aired on October 8 and is part of the network’s weekly rollout at 9 pm ET/PT.