The horrifying murder of The Harper Family

On July 6, 2003, the quiet community of Bakersfield, California, was shaken by the murder of five members of the Harper family: Joanie Harper (39), her mother Ernestine Harper (70), and Joanie’s three children, Marques (4), Lyndsey (23 months), and Marshall (6 weeks). Found shot and, in Joanie’s case, stabbed in their home, the family’s deaths stunned neighbors who knew them for their kindness and community involvement.

The case quickly pointed to Vincent Brothers, Joanie’s husband and father of the children, whose seemingly airtight alibi unraveled under scrutiny. This tragic case of betrayal and violence is remembered as one of Bakersfield’s most shocking crimes.

The case was first explored on Oxygen's Family Massacre season 1, episode 4, and is set to re-air on August 8, 2025, on Oxygen.

The crime scene and discovery of the Harper Family

The five victims were all shot with a .22-caliber handgun. (Image via Unsplash/ @ Maxim Hopman)

A family friend found Joanie Harper, her mother, Ernestine, and her three young children dead in their Bakersfield house on July 8, 2003, after Joanie failed to attend church. The five victims were all shot with a .22-caliber handgun, and Joanie had also been stabbed. The house appeared to have been ransacked, but valuables such as money and electronics had not been disturbed, indicating a staged break-in. Autopsies indicated the murders took place after 1 pm on July 6, according to Oxygen.

The violence of the murders, particularly against young children and a senior woman, caught investigators by surprise. The Harper family was held in high esteem, with Joanie being popular among children and Ernestine for her activism in the civil rights movement. The fact that the murder weapons were missing made the investigation more difficult, but preliminary evidence pointed to the killer having known the family intimately, thus paving the way for an in-depth investigation into their lives, according to NBC News.

The investigation and the suspect

Vincent Brothers, Joanie’s husband, was a main suspect. (Image via Unsplash/ @ Markus Winkler)

Vincent Brothers, Joanie’s husband and a respected vice principal, emerged as the prime suspect despite claiming to be in North Carolina visiting his mother at the time of the murders. Investigators uncovered that Brothers had rented a Dodge Neon in Columbus, Ohio, and driven 5,424 miles to Bakersfield and back, contradicting his alibi, as per NBC News.

Forensic analysis of the car revealed insects native to Southern California, as well as odometer readings consistent with the cross-country trip. Community tips placed Brothers in Bakersfield during the murder window, further undermining his story. The investigation revealed a strained marriage, with the Brothers’ history of extramarital affairs and a prior divorce from Joanie in 2000.

Financial pressures and allegations of domestic violence in his past, including a 1992 spousal abuse conviction, suggested a motive. The prosecution argued the murders were a calculated act to eliminate what Brothers saw as a burden, with the staged crime scene intended to mislead authorities, as per Oxygen.

The trial and conviction

Brothers was convicted of five counts of first-degree murder. (Image via Unsplash/ @ 7500 RPM)

The trial of Vincent Brothers began in January 2007, drawing significant attention as one of Bakersfield’s largest criminal cases. Over four months, 137 witnesses testified, detailing the Brothers’ deceptive alibi and forensic evidence tying him to the crime. Prosecutors highlighted the rental car’s insect evidence and mileage, alongside the Brothers’ inconsistent statements, as per Oxygen.

The defense argued there was insufficient direct evidence, emphasizing his distance from the crime scene and claiming his affairs occurred during a separation. On May 15, 2007, Brothers was convicted of five counts of first-degree murder with a special circumstance of multiple murders. Two weeks later, the jury recommended the death penalty on September 27, 2007, as per KGET.

Brothers was sent to San Quentin’s death row, where he remains pending appeal. The case left a lasting impact, with surviving family members, including Joanie’s stepdaughter, pursuing restitution and distancing themselves from Brothers.

Rewatch Oxygen's Family Massacre season 1, episode 4, The Harper Family on August 8.

About the author

Arvind Singh covers anime and pop culture at Sportskeeda, with a knack for capturing the essence of entertainment through his words. Although he graduated with a BSc in Transportation Technology, his interest in pop culture was ingrained in him from a young age. Witnessing Michael Jackson’s live concert on TV at just 4 years old ignited a lifelong admiration for diverse music and storytelling.

Arvind’s experience includes over a year as an Anime Writer for Sportskeeda, alongside contributions to GameRant’s anime division. He also held a position as a UK Custom Export Executive at Aquatic Freights Pvt. Ltd before delving into the world of journalistic writing. He is dedicated to ethical and relevant reporting through his meticulous sourcing of facts, ensuring he only conveys accurate information devoid of any bias.

In his leisure time, Arvind enjoys listening to rock music, writing poetry, and playing adventure video games. He admires the charisma of icons like Shahrukh Khan, the eloquence of Matthew McConaughey, and the smooth yet powerful vocals of Chester Bennington. Writing is an integral part of his life, and when it comes to expressing his interest and putting a whole scene into words, he could do it all day.

Know More