"She's gonna use AEW just like Mariah May did" - Fans react after another female star announces she's joining All Elite Wrestling

Fans believe AEW's newest signee might leave the promotion, similar to Mariah May. The Glamour had a great run in the Jacksonville-based promotion over the past couple of years.

Mariah quickly became the top star in the company and even held the Women's World Championship for a significant number of days. However, she made a surprise debut in WWE on June 3 after her profile was removed from the AEW roster page.

Recently, popular star and Will Ospreay's partner, Alex Windsor, was featured on a Pro Wrestling Eve show. She has been one of the most talented wrestlers on the independent circuit. The 31-year-old has over 16 years of experience in the ring.

After her performance, Windsor took the microphone, bid farewell to the independent scene for now, and announced that she is All Elite. Alex received a huge ovation from the fans following the surprising announcement.

Expand Tweet

While many fans were happy to see Alex Windsor receive a new deal, others believed she might use AEW as a stepping stone to go to WWE, similar to what Mariah May did.

Take a look at the reactions below:

Bill Apter was surprised to see Mariah May in NXT

The former AEW Women's World Champion's profile was removed from the official AEW roster page on May 30, 2025. Days after her departure, she made her debut on NXT.

While speaking on UnSkripted, Bill Apter expressed his belief that Mariah May could make her debut at Evolution 2 and have a run on the main roster afterward.

"Did you think they were gonna start her off in NXT? I did not. I thought they were gonna debut her maybe at Evolution, and then bring her on to one of the main rosters. So, I am surprised that they brought her into NXT. But maybe a good move to get some more people to watch it," he said.

It remains to be seen how WWE books Mariah May in the future.

About the author

Tejas has been an AEW writer at Sportskeeda Wrestling since 2021. Possessing a degree in Food Processing Technology, it was his brother who introduced him to Sportskeeda, and he has never looked back since.

Tejas’ writing style is analytical and descriptive style, mostly sticking to statistics. He believes in thoroughly checking all statistics and information before using them in his articles to ensure his readers get nothing but the best and most accurate stories. He also does not indulge much in speculation in his content.

His all-time favorite wrestler is Roman Reigns for his journey from being one of the most unlikable babyfaces at the start of his career to one of the greatest modern WWE superstars. If Tejas ever got the chance to go back to the Attitude Era and manage a superstar, it would choose high-flying, risk-taking diminutive entertainer Spike Dudley. Tejas would assure him that he would be involved in long-term storylines, something that he wasn’t part of during his time.

In his free time, Tejas enjoys singing and learning new things.

Know More

Edited by Neda Ali