"Completely absurd": Fans react to MLB Network's top 10 second basemen list as Mookie Betts gets listed as the best

MLB Network’s recent unveiling of the Top 10 Second Baseman list has ignited a firestorm of controversy among baseball enthusiasts, and the epicenter of the upheaval is the unexpected placement of Mookie Betts at the coveted No. 1 spot. This surprising ranking has led fans to collectively declare the decision as a bad pick, triggering a flurry of reactions on social media.

The list – which features notable second basemen like Jose Altuve, Marcus Semien and Luis Arraez – took an unconventional turn by anointing Betts as the premier second baseman. While Betts is undeniably a baseball sensation, his claim to the top spot at this specific position left fans scratching their heads and voicing their dissent:

"This may be the worst list ever created." - Posted one disappointed fan.

A look at Mookie Betts’ 2023 campaign

Mookie Betts – renowned for his exceptional performances as an outfielder, particularly since arriving at the Los Angeles Dodgers – had a stellar 2023 campaign. The season was marked by his offensive prowess, amassing 39 home runs and 107 RBIs. However, fans are quick to point out that these achievements came while Betts predominantly played in the outfield, making the designation of him as the second baseman a head-scratching decision.

As fans expressed their disbelief, many took to social media to share their reactions, questioning the methodology behind the list and the rationale for Bett’s placement. The consensus among fans is that while Betts is undoubtedly a top-tier player, his skills and impact are more aligned with his natural outfield position:

"This is a pathetic and ridiculous list." - Added another fan.

In reflecting on Betts’ standout 2023 MLB season, fans acknowledged his excellence on the field, highlighting his Silver Slugger Award and contributing to the Dodgers. However, the discussion takes a turn when examining Betts’ postseason performance, with a notable disappearance offensively during the playoffs.

While the MLB Network’s rankings are meant to generate discussion and debate, the decision to crown Mookie Betts as the best second baseman has certainly achieved its goal, captivating fans and sparking a lively conversation about the nuances of player positions and their corresponding accolades.

As the baseball community continues to dissect this unexpected ranking, one thing is for certain – Mookie Betts’ name will be at the forefront of "Hot Stove" discussions for weeks to come.