New York Yankees second baseman Jazz Chisholm Jr. made a huge error that could potentially end their postseason. The misplay happened in the seventh inning that derailed a possible double play and extended the inning for the Toronto Blue Jays.With one out and Ernie Clement on first, Andrés Giménez hit a one-hop ground ball up the middle. Chisholm Jr. mishandled the ball as it deflected onto the outfield, leading to the Blue Jays setting up runners on corners and continuing the inning rather than going into the dugout. What followed was a two-run single from Nathan Lukes, extending Toronto's lead to 4-1.This has many fans blasting Chisholm Jr. for giving his opponents a game-winning edge."They wanna give this man $30m+ a year 😭😭😭" one fan smacked his free agency contract predictions."I’m assuming he’s gonna have his back to the media for postgame interviews now," another fan wrote."He’s just out here aura farming," another sarcastically wrote."Bro looking at his glove like his glove did it😭😂" one fan added."McMahon out there giving up his life for this team and Jazz can’t field a routine ground ball," one fan commented."Stg jazz doesn’t try hard enough," one fan commented.Yankees loses ALDS in four games vs Blue JaysThe Yankees have lost in the ALDS. They started the series losing two straight games, but they ignited hopes among fans by winning Game 3 9-6. They entered Game 4 with hopes of forcing Game 5.The game started with an RBI single from Vladimir Guerrero Jr., putting Toronto in front. Third baseman Ryan McMahon's solo shot in the third tied the game. The Blue Jays took the lead by adding one more run in the fifth inning.As mentioned above, the seventh inning saw a two-run single from Nathan Lukes after the error from Jazz Chisholm Jr., putting the Blue Jays in the driver's seat. The Blue Jays extended their lead with Myles Straw's RBI single. The Yankees loaded the bases in the eighth inning, but Jeff Hoffman retired Austin Wells to end the inning.In the ninth inning, after Hoffman struck out Cody Bellinger, it ended the Yankees' 2025 postseason dreams.