5 biggest transfer flops in Premier League history

Nnanna
There have been multiple big-money moves in the Premier League that have been proven to be wasteful.
There have been multiple big-money moves in the Premier League that have been proven to be wasteful.

With the turn of the century, Premier League clubs started changing owners and improving their financial capacity. Stadiums were revamped, training facilities were improved and sports scientists became a necessity for clubs. It isn't surprising, therefore, that these improved finances began to coincide with record-breaking transfer fees.

In the summer of 2000, Leeds bought Rio Ferdinand for a record €26 million. Only three years earlier, Graeme Le Saux moved to Chelsea for just €10.5 million, which was the highest fee throughout the year. In 2003, Chelsea spent over €70 million in purchasing just three players, including Hernan Crespo.

Prices and transfer costs have only continued to skyrocket and each massive transfer fee only increases the chances of the player equally flopping massively. Sometimes, players aren't able to cope under the pressure of large transfer amounts. Other times, it could be difficulties related to playing in a new league in a different country.

Whatever their reasons, there are quite a few players who have made a big-money move to the Premier League and seem unable to handle the expectations of their new club and fans. Without further ado, let's take a look at five such players, starting with Manchester United's €42.60 million star Veron:


#5 Juan Sebastien Veron | Manchester United

Veron Press Conf X
Veron Press Conf X

Although Manchester United had a winning midfield in Ryan Giggs, Paul Scholes, Roy Keane, and David Beckham, Sir Alex Ferguson made the questionable decision to purchase Juan Sebastien Veron from Lazio for a shocking €42.60 million in 2001.

It seems like an odd decision in hindsight but the legendary manager could never have known how problematic his star signing would be for the Red Devils.

To his credit, Veron started well at Old Trafford. However, the massive transfer fee paid wasn't for him to perform brilliantly once every couple of months. Veron needed to be consistent on the pitch, and once it was clear that he wasn't going to achieve expectations, United sold him for half the price they bought him for just two years earlier.


#4 Andriy Shevchenko | Chelsea

Community Shield: Liverpool v Chelsea
Community Shield: Liverpool v Chelsea

The higher-ups at Chelsea certainly believed that they had carefully analyzed one of the best players in the world at the time: Andriy Shevchenko. A star had been made in AC Milan, he was in his prime and Serie A defenders were looking forward to him leaving.

Shevchenko should have joined Chelsea and put the fear of goals into the Premier League defenders. However, that's not what happened.

Didier Drogba, who Shevchenko was supposed to replace, seemed to have found great form following the latter's arrival at the club. Then-manager Jose Mourinho ultimately decided on playing Drogba in his central striking position while pushing the Russian into a different role on the pitch.

Shevchenko ended up scoring just nine goals in 45 appearances for the Blues. After his second season, Chelsea shipped him off on loan and eventually sold him.

#3 Angel di Maria | Manchester United

Manchester United v Queens Park Rangers - Premier League
Manchester United v Queens Park Rangers - Premier League

Signed on for £67.5 million, then a British transfer record, Angel di Maria started his debut season well, but things went sideways a little too quickly.

After dealing with a hamstring injury, as well as an attempted robbery which was clearly unsettling, Di Maria couldn't seem to regain his confidence and form at Old Trafford. He score just four goals in 32 appearances for Manchester United.

The Red Devils eventually breathed a sigh of relief when they sold him off to Paris Saint-Germain by the end of the star's debut season. His selling price at the time was nearly seven times lower the amount United bought him for.


#2 Radamel Falcao | Manchester United

Leicester City v Manchester United - Premier League
Leicester City v Manchester United - Premier League

For a classy player who was an exceptional goalscorer during his time at Atletico Madrid, the one season Radamel Falcao spent on loan at Manchester United was mediocre, at best. He was unable to provide the goals he so freely scored in Spain and France and it wasn't long before he was taken out of the starting lineup.

It could have been called just a bad spell, but his goal droughts were rather long and consistent. By the end of the season, Falcao had scored only four goals in all competitions.

The buy-clause in his loan deal was left untouched by Louis van Gaal and Falcao returned to Monaco. He would later go on another loan move to Chelsea but his Premier League goalscoring woes would continue with the Blues as well.


#1 Adrian Mutu | Chelsea

Adrian Mutu of Chelsea starts to celebrate scoring a goal but it was later disallowed.
Adrian Mutu of Chelsea starts to celebrate scoring a goal but it was later disallowed.

Adrian Mutu's eventful exit from Stamford Bridge took the whole world by storm. The star played brilliantly in Serie A before joining the Blues and he even started off on the right foot during his debut season in England. However, Mutu would go on to test positive for cocaine after failing a drug test.

While the star was banned from playing football for seven months, Chelsea terminated his contract and sued him. The club was successful, with the courts ruling that Mutu had to pay Chelsea a fee near the cost of his transfer: €17 million. Adrian Mutu would later go on to play for Fiorentina, where he failed yet another doping test.

Quick Links

Edited by Ritwik Kumar