5 club flops who actually had a great impact on their teams

Fernando Torres at Chelsea
Fernando Torres at Chelsea.

While the players will be away on international duty for the Euros and Copa America at the end of this season, clubs will be hard at work in the upcoming summer transfer window. This window is known for some of the biggest splurges, with many players changing allegiances - and this summer’s window promises to be no different.

When a new player arrives at a club, he generally brings forth massive expectations from the fans. Sometimes, the new arrivals cannot match these high expectation levels and might be regarded as “flops,” but they play a significant role during their stay at the club. While stats have significance, there are many things that happen on a football pitch that they cannot accurately reflect.

Today, let’s take a look at:


5 club flops who actually had a great impact


#5 Gareth Bale | Real Madrid

Real Madrid v Liverpool - UEFA Champions League Final
Real Madrid v Liverpool - UEFA Champions League Final

The Welshman made headlines after a then-world record transfer fee of £85.3 million - bringing him to Madrid from London. The fee and his reputation brought about huge expectations from the fans, and after being loaned back to his former club Spurs, Bale’s time at Los Blancos feels numbered.

However, Bale was an essential player for Madrid, especially in the first few years of his stint at the club. Bale was involved in 41 goals from 44 appearances in his debut season, including 6 goals and 4 assists in the 2013/14 Champions League - helping Los Blancos lift a record 10th title.

Bale went on to win 4 Champions League titles with Madrid, and was an integral part of the “BBC” trio, which included Cristiano Ronaldo and Karim Benzema. However, the Welshman’s most memorable Champions League moment was perhaps the overhead kick stunner, followed by a long-range strike, against Liverpool in the 2018 Champions League finals.

The now-Real Madrid loanee will also be remembered by Madridistas for his sensational solo goal against Barcelona in the Copa Del Rey final, in which he sprinted past Marc Batra after being shoved off the touchline.


#4 Mario Götze | Bayern Munich

Borussia Dortmund v FC Bayern Muenchen - Bundesliga
Borussia Dortmund v FC Bayern Muenchen - Bundesliga

Götze was one of the biggest names in world football, particularly in the early 2010s, when he played a vital role in Borussia Dortmund’s title run in the Bundesliga - the only club to deny Bayern the trophy in 11 seasons. This, combined with the German’s heroic goal in the World Cup final against Argentina, propelled Götze's stature as one of the finest in world football.

Götze followed his Dortmund teammate, Robert Lewandowski, to Allianz Arena, and while the Polish remains one of Bayern’s best ever players, the former currently plies his trade at PSV Eindhoven. However, the German made a significant impact in his first couple of seasons at Bayern. Götze’s first season at the Allianz Arena was nothing short of a fairytale - with the attacking midfielder/false 9 being involved in 19 goals (10 goals, 9 assists) in 20 appearances in the Bundesliga.

The following season for 28-year-old was marred by injuries, and yet he managed a return of 15 goals and 7 assists from 28 starts.

However, Pep Guardiola shifted away from the use of a false nine as he did with Lionel Messi at Barcelona, and instead laid emphasis on proven strikers up front - the likes of Lewandowski and Mandzukic. This led to Götze spending more time on the bench and, leading to him losing his confidence. Injuries and a serious metabolic illness also severely affected the talented player. After three years at the Allianz Arena, the German returned home to Borussia, before moving to PSV Eindhoven at the beginning of the 2020/21 season.

#3 Paulinho | Barcelona

Sevilla v FC Barcelona - La Liga
Sevilla v FC Barcelona - La Liga

Taking the third spot on the podium is arguably the greatest one-season cameo in footballing history. In a star-studded Barcelona team - comprising the likes of Messi and Iniesta, along with a host of midfielders - Paulinho earned a regular spot in the XI, playing a massive role in the club’s domestic double.

Paulinho’s €40 million move from Guangzhou Evergrande shocked many, as the Brazilian was not in touch with the high-intensity levels in European football - after three seasons in China. Initially relegated to the bench, Paulinho worked his way into the starting XI, and enjoyed a return of 9 goals and 2 assists from 21 starts in La Liga.

Barcelona had a stellar outing in the 2014/15 season, winning La Liga and Copa Del Rey, with the Brazilian coming in as Barcelona’s third-highest scorer in La Liga, only behind Messi and Suarez. This is no mean feat, and the Brazilian managed to achieve it as a midfielder.

While Paulinho’s signing came out of the blue, his departure from the club was even stranger. After a loan move the following season to Guangzhou Evergrande, Paulinho permanently moved back to China once again - helping Guangzhou lift their 6th title in his homecoming.


#2 Zlatan Ibrahimovic | Barcelona

Arsenal v Barcelona - UEFA Champions League
Arsenal v Barcelona - UEFA Champions League

Next up, we have another former Barcelona man, Zlatan Ibrahimovic. The out-spoken Swede’s public feud with then-manager Pep Guardiola is common knowledge and is widely regarded as a failure at Barcelona. However, his stats for Blaugrana are evidence of the enormous impact he made in a brief period of time.

Zlatan was involved in 34 goals (22 goals, 12 assists) from 46 appearances for Barcelona, and was excellent in hold-up play, along with extreme precision in front of goal. The Swede enjoyed a fantastic start to life as a Catalonian, scoring 7 goals in his first seven La Liga games. While Pep and Barcelona were intent on displaying a “beautiful” brand of football, Zlatan showed time and again that a long ball over the top, coupled with precise shooting, can also lead to a goal in fewer touches.

Gotze suffered because Pep moved away from the use of a false 9 and midfielders in central positions - replacing it with traditional strikers. During Zlatan’s time at Barcelona, Pep did things the other way round, which did not suit the Swede’s playing style. Zlatan’s short stint at Barcelona is evidence of the club’s misgivings in the transfer market, and while “tiki-taka” worked brilliantly for Pep & Co., it wouldn’t have hurt to keep a solid Plan B.


#1 Fernando Torres | Chelsea

FC Barcelona v Chelsea FC - UEFA Champions League Semi Final
FC Barcelona v Chelsea FC - UEFA Champions League Semi Final

Taking pole position is one of the most polarising transfers in modern football, when El Nino shocked one and all after parting ways with Liverpool - ending a 4-year association with the club. Torres arrived at Stamford Bridge on a then-Premier League record fee of £52.65million.

El Nino arrived with massive expectations, and while the neutral may regard him as a “flop” for Chelsea and remember him only for that open-goal miss against Manchester United, the Blues’ faithful will know that’s far from the truth.

Torres’ time at Chelsea did not start off well as he failed to find the back of the net in his first 903 minutes for the West Londoners. However, Torres will be regarded as a “hero” for the Blues, thanks in part to his heroic display in the 2011/12 Champions League. The Spaniard scored three goals in the CL, including the memorable semi-final winner against Barcelona - helping Chelsea lift their first-ever Champions League title.

Torres will also be remembered for a Beckham-esque cross in the Champions League final, which was headed in by Drogba in the 93rd, forcing extra-time and penalties. Despite being regarded as a “flop”, El Nino is a hero for the Blues.

Quick Links

Edited by S Chowdhury