5 Manchester United players who need to be dropped from the starting lineup

Manchester United were one of the best sides in the Premier League last term. Though they finished second in the league, they were well behind eventual winners Manchester City. But Ole Gunnar Solskjaer's men were able to do the league double over their rivals.

They played some entertaining football in the 2020-21 season and were unfortunate to have lost the Europa League final in a shootout. But that meant Solskjaer remained trophyless yet another season as Manchester United manager.

Time for Solskjaer to be ruthless with this Manchester United squad

Despite strengthening over the summer, Manchester United seem to have regressed this season. There's none of the bravery or commitment that we saw last season. They have struggled to stamp their authority on games and have been shockingly ordinary in defence.

Ole Gunnar Solskjaer remains in his job for now but if things continue to deteriorate, he will be replaced soon. One thing is for certain and it is that something has got to give. They need to get back to winning ways and Solskjaer has to make some harsh decisions.

---

#5 David de Gea

Manchester United v Manchester City - Premier League

This might be a divisive call, but David de Gea is not beyond criticism. He cannot escape it because he made a few really good saves in the first half against Manchester City and largely kept United in the game. Yes, De Gea was Manchester United's best player in the match but he still makes grave errors at crucial times.

De Gea has made two errors leading to goals in the last two matches alone. His poor decision-making led to Atalanta's first goal in the Champions League game which ended in a 2-2 draw.

De Gea was also reluctant to come off his line as Zapata scored his side's second goal of the game. By sticking to the goalline, De Gea made it easy for the Colombian international to put the ball past him.

Although De Gea made a raft of top saves against City, he was guilty of conceding a soft goal. It was not purely his fault but his involvement in it cannot be overlooked. Luke Shaw let the ball run across himself when he shouldn't have done so but Bernardo Silva had no business scoring from such an acute angle.

De Gea should have easily palmed it away. But he didn't even get a good contact on the ball and it hit his body and it awkwardly fell into the netting. The Spaniard's lack of command over his area and inability to sweep behind his underperforming defenders means that Manchester United have to look at an alternative.

We'd have been all for De Gea keeping his place had he been clear of the competition. But in Dean Henderson, Manchester United have a great alternative and it's time he got his shot this season.

#4 Scott McTominay

Manchester United v Manchester City - Premier League

The double midfield pivot of Scott McTominay and Fred is Manchester United's best bet in midfield. But they are so awful that it makes one wonder when the levels at Old Trafford dropped so bad they don't have players who can control games in the centre of the park.

McTominay and Fred were appallingly poor against Manchester City. The duo made one successful tackle in the entire game against City at Old Trafford. The pair were dribbled past a combined eight times. While Fred was at least committing to tackles, the Scotsman was largely invisible.

He offered no threat going forward and no security in defence. Manchester United legend Roy Keane delivered a scathing verdict on the pair after the game and it's difficult to disagree with him.

"They just toyed with United. So poor. Men vs. boys. Foden said it’s a tough place to come - it’s not. Ask Everton. Ask Aston Villa. It’s just so poor. McTominay, Fred - these players aren’t good enough for Manchester United."

#3 Luke Shaw

Manchester United v Atalanta: Group F - UEFA Champions League

Luke Shaw touched world-class levels last season. He was a creative force at left-back, motoring forward and giving Manchester United much-needed thrust down the left side. He was also pretty adept defensively.

Shaw also had a wonderful outing at Euro 2020. However, his levels have dropped to shocking levels this season. He hasn't offered much going forward and has just two assists in 14 appearances this term.

Shaw produced two utterly poor performances against Liverpool and Manchester City. His positioning and decision-making have been suspect all season. However, he looked as lost as a toddler at Pottery Barn, against Liverpool and City, reduced to a mere spectator watching grown-ups go about their business.

He just cannot be allowed to continue in this fashion. The Englishman has to be removed from the first team and given some time to gather his bearings and get his fitness back.

#2 Cristiano Ronaldo

Manchester United v Manchester City - Premier League

Yet another inclusion that could divide opinions. But for the discerning viewer, this has got to be as clear as daylight by now. Cristiano Ronaldo offers goals and vital ones too. But they come at a cost. They could soon come at the cost of Solskjaer's job.

With Ronaldo playing uptop, Manchester United are rigid. Much of their attacking efficiency came from the fluidity of their frontline. With Bruno Fernandes playing much like a false nine and the likes of Rashford, Cavani and Greenwood operating ahead of him, they were unstoppable when they were all on song.

Ronaldo rarely moves to the flanks and doesn't offer much in the build-up. He will be there to finish off moves but it comes at the cost of United's style of play. Since joining the club, Ronaldo has started only one game on the bench. That was the Premier League match against Everton.

Despite the game ending 1-1, Manchester United played some of their best football this season in that first half. Ronaldo's pressing often looks performative and it's quite underwhelming when you compare it to Edinson Cavani's workrate.

No player ought to be undroppable but the Portuguese international seems to have that kind of clout in this Manchester United team now. Solskjaer needs to be ruthless and get his team to play to heir strengths again.

#1 Harry Maguire

Tottenham Hotspur v Manchester United - Premier League

Yes, Harry Maguire was one of the best centre-backs in the Premier League in the 2020-21 season. He is also one of the worst this term. It's astonishing how the Manchester United captain can oscillate between exceptional and downright ordinary.

He looks clueless in the heart of defence and has been dragged around in every single game. Manchester United have not kept a clean sheet in 14 home matches and much of it is down to their underperforming backline.

Carrying the ball forward and playing line-breaking passes has been one of Maguire's strengths. He has been awful at that too this term. Maguire is very clearly what you call a 'confidence player' who just doesn't seem to have any amount of belief in his own abilities right now.

Since Varane is out for at least three more weeks, Maguire might be allowed to continue. But he simply shouldn't be. He might be deployed again by Solskjaer in the hopes that his good qualities will shine through. But it is very evident at this point that Maguire needs some time off.