Manchester United vs Manchester City: Key Talking Points

Manchester United v Manchester City - Premier League
Nicolas Otamendi competes for the ball as Romelu Lukaku looks on

#1 What exactly constitutes a penalty?

Ad
Manchester United v Manchester City - Premier League
Ander Herrera and Nicolas Otamendi square off after the penalty incident

When Nicolas Otamendi made contact with Ander Herrera's foot inside the City box, three things were mighty clear

Ad

a) Otamendi got none of the ball and all of the Spaniard

b) Herrera was going absolutely nowhere with the ball

c) Herrera was quite obviously looking for it.

Now, as per the laws of the game when a) has occurred, does the referee even need to consider b) and c)? Herrera's progress was obviously impeded by Otamendi's errant foot, but does the fact that he may or may not have done something with the ball were it not for Otamendi's challenge have anything at all to do with it?

Ad

Which is why Jose Mourinho was furious at the post-match interview, commending Michael Oliver for a good game (he did have a decent one, allowing the game to flow where many others would have made it a stop-start affair) but saying Oliver spoilt it by this one, game-changing decision.

Pep Guardiola, meanwhile, swatted the question aside - as any winning manager would.

Whether City got the rub of the green or not, the significance of such slices of luck, such decisions going in your favour (each team has this, United themselves were lucky not to concede a penalty at Arsenal... and so and so forth) on the overall title race simply can't be underestimated.

Quick Links

Edited by Anirudh Menon
Sportskeeda logo
Close menu
WWE
WWE
NBA
NBA
NFL
NFL
MMA
MMA
Tennis
Tennis
NHL
NHL
Golf
Golf
MLB
MLB
Soccer
Soccer
F1
F1
WNBA
WNBA
More
More
bell-icon Manage notifications