Below Deck Med's season 8 crew faces fan backlash

Below Deck Med
Fan discontent rises over Below Deck Mediterranean season 8 crew issues (Image via Bravo)

The eighth season of Below Deck Mediterranean has sparked significant fan backlash, primarily due to issues within the crew. Central to the controversy is the drama involving interior team members, notably between Kyle Viljoen and Natalya Scudder, which led to Scudder's departure from the show.

Additionally, leadership challenges have surfaced, with incidents involving Jack Stirrup's disobedience and Luka Brunton's struggles as bosun. These events have not gone unnoticed by Captain Sandy, whose frustration with the crew's performance has been evident. Fans have taken to social media platforms, especially Reddit, to express their disappointment, citing concerns over crew behavior and management decisions.


Below Deck Med season 8 crew drama sparks major fan backlash

The interior team of Below Deck Med season 8 has been at the center of controversy. A significant point of contention was the conflict between Kyle Viljoen and Natalya Scudder. Viljoen's behavior towards Scudder was a key factor in her decision to leave the show, a development that has drawn considerable attention from fans and critics alike.

Leadership within the crew has also faced scrutiny. An incident involving Jack Stirrup highlighted a disregard for authority, as he was noted for disobeying a direct order from Captain Sandy. Furthermore, Luka Brunton, who serves as the bosun, showed difficulties in managing his role effectively. His attempt to leave the yacht mid-season was a clear sign of the challenges faced by the crew in maintaining a cohesive and functional work environment.

On the other hand, Below Deck Med’s Captain Sandy's reaction to these events has been one of clear frustration. Fans feel her responses and actions throughout the season reflect a growing dissatisfaction with the crew's performance, adding to the tension and drama that has come to define this season.

The fan response to the unfolding drama in season 8 has naturally been vocal and widespread. Viewers have expressed their frustrations on various platforms, with X (formerly Twitter) and Reddit being a notable hub for such discussions. Fans have criticized the crew's perceived incompetence, with many questioning the decision-making processes behind the scenes.

X (formerly Twitter) user @RyShan24 expressed strong disappointment with season 8's cast, criticizing the crew's diversity, appearance, and the nature of the drama, urging BravoTV to improve. Meanwhile, another user highlighted Danny's positive impact on guest experiences, suggesting the rest of the Below Deck Med cast could learn from his efforts to enhance guest enjoyment.

The departure of Natalya Scudder, in particular, was a focal point of criticism, as many viewers felt that her capabilities were undervalued in favor of maintaining other, more controversial crew members. Several other netizens took to social media to talk about the recent incidents too.

On Reddit, user u/vanessaismybarname also voiced disappointment.

Fans express discontent (Image via Reddit/ u/vanessaismybarname)
Fans express discontent (Image via Reddit/ u/vanessaismybarname)

While the interior team faced the brunt of the criticism, the deck crew received a mixed response from the audience. Some fans acknowledged the efforts of the rookie members of the deck crew, noting their professionalism in handling challenging situations.


As is evident, the intense focus on internal conflicts and leadership issues has raised questions about the future direction of the series. Viewer engagement, a crucial aspect of any reality TV show, has been affected, with some fans expressing a decrease in interest due to the ongoing drama.

Responses from the Below Deck Med's producers or cast members to the fan backlash have been limited. However, these reactions are critical in understanding how the show might adapt and evolve in response to viewer feedback. The handling of crew dynamics, casting decisions, and portrayal of events on the yacht are likely to be areas of focus in future seasons.

Quick Links

App download animated image Get the free App now