Fantasy Island season 2 episode 1 recap: The high-school return and the cat companion 

A still from Fantasy Island (Image via FOX)
A still from Fantasy Island (Image via FOX)

Fantasy Island season 2 premiered on January 2, 2023, with its original format of guests trying to indulge in their fantasies, albeit for a brief period of time. The spinoff/sequel to the original ABC program saw a hit first season, and as it turns out, the second season has also kicked off on an exciting note.

The first episode of Fox's Fantasy Island episode 2 followed two friends, Tara (Rachael Harris) and Jessica (Cheryl Hines), who have been relentlessly bullied since high school, as they try to seek some sort of redemption through a school reunion. The other major character was Andi (Jasika Nicole), who wanted to know if her ginger cat, Baron BoBo VonBigglesworth III, loved her as much as she loved him.

Like other episodes, this one is also riddled with subplots, including one with Ruby (Kiara Barnes) and Gina's (played by Gabriela Hernandez) breakup.


Fantasy Island season 2, episode 1 recap: The road not traveled

Fox's Fantasy Island season 2 kicked off with some internal drama on the island involving Elena Roarke (Roselyn Sánchez) and Xavier (John Gabriel Rodriquez). Amid this, a new set of guests arrived, who were intent on living their fantasies.

High school friends Tara and Jessica have been professional partners since high school ended and now run a company that gives them little time for themselves. Meanwhile, Andi, another guest who has let her past experiences affect her negatively, hangs on to only the small things she loves.

As the island has the ability to show people what could be or could have been, Tara and Jessica get to see what might have happened had they made different life choices, while Andi learns about how Bobo really feels when he is turned into a human.

By the end of Fantasy Island season 2, episode 1, Elena realizes that Tara and Jessica were not keeping up with each other but holding each other back. If they took their separate paths, they could have achieved their own version of happiness, but they are instead struck trying to repair the damage that should not matter any more.

Following this realization, the duo decided to split ways and pursue their separate paths. They are likely to still be friends but not in a mutually dependent manner.

On the other hand, Andi realized how much she shut herself off from the world and why she is obsessed with her pet. When Bobo becomes human and shares some observations with her, she is forced to evaluate her life and choices. She also hit it off with a staff member at the hotel, indicating that she was ready to move ahead now.

The first episode of Fantasy Island also depicted Gina and Ruby's breakup. This seems to be something that has been coming for quite some time, and it could lead both the characters to a new and more interesting place.


Fantasy Island season 2 will return on January 9, 2023, with some new stories and new characters. Stay tuned for more updates.

Quick Links

App download animated image Get the free App now