Who are the P.I. Moms and where are they now? All you need to know before you watch the 7th Trainwreck documentary

P.I. Moms were four suburban moms who were hired as private investigators and had their reality show future interrupted by crime and scandal. Michelle Allen, Charmagne Peters, Denise Antoon, and Ami Wiltz, known as the P.I. Moms, were poised for reality television fame through a Lifetime series that was never aired as they worked for Butler & Associates, a Bay Area investigation firm headed by Chris Butler, an ex-cop.

Trainwreck: P.I. Moms, the next chapter of Netflix’s Trainwreck documentary series, tells the astonishing story of the short-lived rise and dramatic collapse of a reality TV show that never aired.

However, staged cases and crime involving drugs and police corruption eventually shut the entire operation down. The women are now away from the limelight, and none of them are private investigators. The documentary series is set to stream on July 22, 2025.

---

Who were the P.I. Moms?

The P.I. Moms were four women, namely Allen, Peters, Antoon, and Wiltz, who were marketed as everyday mothers who were trained undercover investigators. They joined Chris Butler's firm in Concord, California, around 2010.

Butler, a former police officer, believed that moms had certain qualities that would contribute significantly to investigative work; they were patient, emotionally intelligent, and they could blend into any environment. The women were trained in surveillance, interviewing, and self-defense.

The firm worked on various cases that included insurance fraud and suspected infidelity, which grabbed national media attention and paved the way for appearances on Dr. Phil and 48 Hours.

Trainwreck P.I Moms on Netflix (Image via Unsplash/@ Moritz Karst)

These media representations concluded with a deal made with Lifetime for a reality TV show called P.I. Moms, which was scheduled to premiere in 2011. During this time, they were depicted as regular heroes balancing motherhood with dangerous work in the field.

But just as quickly, questions began to arise about the operations they were conducting. It was once again journalist Peter Crooks, who, at this time, was on the team at Butler's firm as part of a story, who learned that the Case was a complete sham.

The scandal only intensified when it was revealed that Butler (and his partner, drug task force commander Norman Wielsch) were both reselling seized narcotics and engaged in drug dealings of other types.

---

Where are the P.I. Moms now?

The collapse of the show occurred quickly in early 2011. Once the news developed, it was revealed that Chris Butler was embroiled in serious criminal activity related to drug trafficking and illegal surveillance.

Butler, along with Norman Wielsch, a captain in the Contra Costa County Narcotics Task Force, was busted for stealing and selling confiscated drugs. Both men were sentenced; Butler to eight years in federal prison.

Trainwreck P.I Moms on Netflix (Image via Unsplash/@Jakob Owens)

Michelle Allen, Charmagne Peters, Denise Antoon, and Ami Wiltz were not implicated in these crimes, and they stated they had no idea illegal operations were occurring behind the scenes.

Even without their involvement in completing the rumors, these women's reputations were damaged, the show was canceled prior to airing, and the women retreated from public life.

As per RadioTimes, none of the P.I. Moms are known to be working as investigators. Denise Antoon had a history of a criminal background but returned to a different career path, possibly in education.

Ami Wiltz, who expressed herself when she appeared on 48 Hours and Dr. Phil, said that she could not believe Butler had betrayed their trust. Allen and Peters are still out of the spotlight, and there are currently no active public profiles available for these women as professionals.

---

Watch The Trainwreck: P.I. Moms documentary, streaming on Netflix from July 22, 2025.