#2 Michaels could be stalling

Another possibility here could be that Michaels is simply stalling. His return to the ring was at a Saudi Arabian show.
Michaels has earned the nickname of Mr. WrestleMania, thanks to his legendary performances at The Show of Shows throughout his career. What if he wants to have a last hurrah at 'Mania?
When scripted fights get too real - Watch Here!
Styles told Kelley that Michaels said no to his offer, but what if Michaels just isn't ready for a match yet, and wants to wrestle his final match at a WrestleMania?
If this is indeed the case, one can hope that WWE brings back Michaels for a dream match against AJ Styles at WrestleMania 36. After all, a match of this caliber deserves to take place at WrestleMania.
Also read: 5 times Vince McMahon abruptly canceled a Superstar's push
#1 Michaels probably thinks the ship has sailed for this particular match

Back in the early to late 2000s, Shawn Michaels was enjoying a second run in WWE, and was having amazing bouts one after the other.
At the same time, AJ Styles was building a career in Impact Wrestling. Both Superstars were at their absolute best at the time, and a match between the two could have been an instant 5-star classic!
More than a decade later, Michaels is 54 and his body isn't capable of doing what it used to do back in the day.
Maybe Michaels is aware of the fact that a match against Styles will do nothing but irk the fans, as they won't be getting the masterpiece that these two would have presented in the 2000s.
These wrestling matches are not 'fake' at all - Watch!