#4 Shinsuke Nakamura

An unlikely choice for champion at the moment, especially since his damaging feud with Mahal for the past few months and a general malaise after his promotion to the main brand from NXT, Nakamura still possesses enormous charisma and a capacity to thrill a crowd in the ring.
His mic skills in English may be primitive and stilted, but in the hands of someone as talented as he is, it somehow fits in a strange and enigmatic way.
Look who just shut down all of Tony Khan's critics! More HERE.
The bonus effect of having someone relatively uncomfortable in promos would also mean no 20-minute talking segments that feel like they last an hour, with Nakamura letting his Kinshasa do most of the talking for him.