#3 Mickie James
Mickie James returned to WWE just two years ago as she teamed up with Alexa Bliss. Since then she has received quite a few title opportunities, but unluckily she was unable to capture the title and become an eight-time women's champion.
The current situation with James is that she's not winning many matches, which means that she didn't put over those stars who have beaten her. The motive of her return to WWE was to make other superstars rise in the game by putting them over her.
But unfortunately, Mickie has failed to do so. Though the 6-time women's champion has some astonishing accolades, it's not helping current stars in any way.