#1 Carlito Colon

Having over 20 years of experience in the sport and being gone long enough, Carlito will get a reaction if he were to return. He started his wrestling career in World Wrestling Council and it was a wise decision by the WWE that they hired him right away.
Despite achieving little in the WWE, the former Intercontinental champion will still get a reaction out of the crowd and be a welcome addition to the current roster if he were to sign. The tournament will have a lot of talent in it and he will stand out.
WWE's huge mistake with John Cena revealed - Watch Here!
If he were to come back to the WWE, I can see him either as a wrestler or a manager for Epico and Primo, assuming those two ever come back at any point.
Who else do you want to see in the tournament?
Paul Heyman's downfall need to be studied - Check!