#1 Cody Rhodes

The son of the American Dream Dusty Rhodes has become an international superstar all on his own volition.
Why he was fired/released: Cody asked for his release from the company after disillusionment about his Stardust character's 'tacky' costumes, many of which he claimed fit poorly and were difficult to wrestle in, as well as frustration with his inability to climb to the main event.
WWE has no plans for these former AEW wrestlers? Here's why!
Why they should hire him back: Cody has proven in New Japan, ROH, and smaller promotions that he can sell out venues and have stellar matches with almost anyone. A feud with AJ Styles or Brock Lesnar would generate a great deal of interest.
How WWE has messed up John Cena's last run - Check here!