1: Corey Graves

Corey Graves was an NXT Tag-Team Champion before his career was tragically cut short. Thankfully Graves successfully transitioned to a career on the commentary table in NXT. After honing his skills, he successfully moved up to RAW and is now also the colour commentator on SmackDown Live.
Graves appeared in WWE 2K15 but will now appear in WWE 2K18 as a commentator. I know I said no one from 2K18 would be on this list, but since Graves will be on commentary I guess I can give myself a pass.
WWE's huge mistake with John Cena revealed - Watch Here!
Which other WWE Superstars have appeared in only one WWE game? Sound off on the comments below and follow me on Twitter @pratyayghSK.
Paul Heyman's downfall need to be studied - Check!