8. Phantasio

This gimmick was so bad, it only lasted for one match!
Phatasio was portrayed by journeyman grappler Harry Del Rios. With ratings down, and PPV buyrates in a downward spiral, the WWE decided to focus on 'flashy' gimmicks that would be easy to understand for children.
Did Goldberg ruin Bray Wyatt's career? - Watch Now!
Phantasio's big move was 'magically' making his opponent's boxer shorts fly off, and rolling them up for a pin. He also removed Earl Hebner's boxers, which ended up being striped like a referee's uniform.
After one appearance on television, Phantasio worked one more dark match for WWE and the gimmick was retired. You might say it disappeared in a puff of smoke!
One wrong move ended Big E's career - Watch Here!