#24 It was better the first time (WrestleMania 29)
In contrast to the hype of their first match, few fans were interested in seeing the repeat. It felt derivative going in, and the match felt even more so. The first match wasn't a masterpiece by any means, but it had a glowing spectacle which hid its deficiencies. That spectacle was gone the second time, because we'd already seen it before.
There was also little doubt that Cena would win this time around, with the title being on the line and all. So it was, and Cena got that one final torch passed to him before his own career would start winding down.
In contrast to previous endings, there wasn't anything actively bad about this one, but it was far from inspired, and CM Punk's long title reign coming to an end to set this match up left a bad taste in many fans' mouths.