Who Does it Better? Episode 1: The Shield

Round 2: Charisma

Charisma is a malleable thing. Sometimes it's evident when a person talks. Other times, it comes through in a person's mannerisms. Charisma isn't just about being liked, but it's also about being memorable, connecting with people, and getting them invested in you.

None of the Shield members are exactly overflowing with charisma, but Dean Ambrose has had the most memorable personality of the three of them.

Seth Rollins comes in second place. While he's not as unique a character as Dean Ambrose is, he's had an organic connection with crowds that makes them want to cheer him, to the point that his return from injury two years ago was widely criticized because he didn't turn babyface. That babyface connection has been fully forged this year.

Roman Reigns' personality, or lack thereof, has been criticized ever since his push to the top of the card began four years ago. His lack of a character and failure to evolve past the Shield has hurt his ability to inspire devotion in fans, and while crowds are certainly invested in him, that has come because of his booking more than him.

Verdict:

1st: Dean Ambrose (+3 points)

2nd: Seth Rollins (+2 points)

3rd: Roman Reigns (+1 point)