Who Does it Better? Episode 1: The Shield

Round 5: Versatility

Last, but not least is the ability to be versatile. How do the other four categories come together to paint an overall picture, and how flexible can the performers be with their skills?

At first glance, Seth Rollins might be the complete package, given his mixture of talent in the ring, good look, and passable skill on the mic, but his run as a cowardly heel champion in 2015 suggests otherwise. Seth Rollins' skills don't come together well to play a heel.

In contrast, Roman Reigns is being ill-served by his booking. He's a natural heel and his weaknesses in his character and talking ability would be solved by a heel turn, though he can also put on matches to a degree befitting a babyface if only they wouldn't be overbooked to try and get him sympathy.

Dean Ambrose, though, is the most versatile of the three. He can play the heel or the babyface very well. He can deliver heel or babyface promos at his leisure and has the look and skills in the ring to play either role. Many fans are clamoring for him to turn since it's been such a long time since we've seen a heel Dean Ambrose, but he still excels as a likable babyface.

Verdict:

1st: Dean Ambrose (+3 points)

2nd: Roman Reigns (+2 points)

3rd: Seth Rollins (+1 point)