Conclusion
1st: Dean Ambrose - 13 points
One wrong move ruined his entire WWE career - Watch Now!
2nd: Seth Rollins - 9 points
3rd: Roman Reigns - 8 points
It might be a surprising conclusion, but Dean Ambrose excels in the most places when it comes to being a great professional wrestler, even though he's been the least pushed of the three Shield members. The fact that he's maintained his popularity through doldrums such as his feud with The Miz suggests his power - compare with Rollins' underwhelming WWE Championship reign and the numerous bad angles involving Roman Reigns over the past few years.
There's no doubt that improving his look helped Ambrose's standing as well. His most glaring weakness as a professional wrestler was thus solved.
Seth Rollins has had a revelation of a year and found his stride as a babyface, where he was always meant to be. Unfortunately, his second reign as Intercontinental Champion has taken a backseat to the Shield reunion, which is preventing him from shining brightest where he does best - wrestle in the ring.
Roman Reigns continues to be booked poorly, with a ton of smoke and mirrors with every match now. If only he would turn heel, he would probably explode, as his promos would likely improve, and his delivery would better fit that role. Unfortunately, Vince McMahon continues to try to put a square peg into a round hole, failing Reigns and the audience.
A top WWE star is missing in action