Mets fans split on news that team is considering Andrew McCutchen in the outfield: "Would be solid" "Maybe about five years ago"

Milwaukee Brewers v Tampa Bay Rays
Could the Mets sign Andrew McCutchen?

Andrew McCutchen could find a new team soon. Despite everything the New York Mets have gone through, they're still active in free agency and are reportedly interested in the former Milwaukee Brewers outfielder.

It would be in a bench role since the Mets already employ Mark Canha, Starling Marte and just signed Brandon Nimmo to a huge contract this offseason. McCutchen would be the fourth outfielder and likely the first player off the bench.

Mets considering Andrew McCutchen among 4th OF

Jon Heyman reports that the Mets are looking at a lot of options for their fourth outfielder and have shown interest in the former Pittsburgh Pirates standout.

Mets fans are split on whether or not this is good news. Many believe McCutchen's prime is well behind him and others think he can still be serviceable off the bench.

@JonHeyman No thanks .. Maybe about 5yrs ago
@JonHeyman Would be solid. Need a 4th OF heading into spring.
@JonHeyman He would be really good 17 hrs last year DH/4th OF has a lot of experience. And literally my favorite players as a kid
@JonHeyman As a Brewer fan who saw him hit last year, you’ll want him as a 4th outfielder who can give guys rest. Especially if you’re going up against a lefty.
@JonHeyman If he can play the field some and DH. I don’t mind this idea.
@JonHeyman Don’t hate it. He would be the 4th outfielder/DH. Won’t cost a lot and he can’t be worse than Ruf. Don’t really see the down side
@JonHeyman Avg and obp plummeting the past 3 years. He’s really cool as a person though
@JonHeyman Guys washed but we passed on correa right 🤦🏻‍♂️
@JonHeyman I'd rather Profar for OF and Duvall for RH DH with a side of Chafin for pen.
@JonHeyman Great replacement for Correa

The Mets struck out on Carlos Correa after weeks of feeling like he was coming to the team. They signed him to a massive contract before physical issues derailed it, allowing the Minnesota Twins to sneak in and sign him.

Now, since there aren't any superstars available on the market, the Mets are forced to simply look at depth. Players like McCutchen can provide that, though some fans still believe there are better options out there.

Where does Andrew McCutchen fit in the Mets lineup?

As mentioned, Andrew McCutchen would be a fourth outfielder, but he could also be the DH from time to time as well. Currently, Daniel Vogelbach is the DH, but he could sit when the Mets face a lefty.

If so, that opens the door for McCutchen to get even more playing time. Here's how the lineup might look:

  1. Brandon Nimmo, CF
  2. Starling Marte, RF
  3. Francisco Lindor, SS
  4. Pete Alonso, 1B
  5. Jeff McNeil, 2B
  6. Daniel Vogelbach/ Andrew McCutchen, DH
  7. Eduardo Escobar, 3B
  8. Mark Canha, LF
  9. Omar Narvaez, C

McCutchen also has the ability to spell either Canha, Nimmo or Marte. He's a centerfielder by trade but has transitioned to corner outfield spots before.

The Mets would shore up their bench and provide themselves with a steady former MVP who can give them versatility. This would be a good signing.

Quick Links

Edited by Zachary Roberts
Be the first one to comment