"It would be unfair" - Shardul Thakur reacts to substitute debate amid Rishabh Pant's injury in 4th ENG vs IND 2025 Test

England v India - 4th Rothesay Test Match: Day Two - Source: Getty
Rishabh Pant walked out to bat with a fractured toe on Day 2 of the Manchester Test. (Image Credits: Getty Images)

Team India all-rounder Shardul Thakur has opined that any new rule allowing a substitute to replace an injured player in Test cricket should come into effect only from the next World Test Championship (WTC) cycle. He stated that introducing a new substitution rule in the ongoing WTC cycle would be unfair.

Ad

A debate over allowing a badly injured player in a Test match to be replaced by a substitute, who can bat and bowl, has gained momentum after Rishabh Pant fractured his toe in the ongoing India-England Test in Manchester. While Dhruv Jurel is keeping wickets due to Pant's injury, he is not allowed to bat as per current rules. As a result, Pant walked out to bat despite a fractured toe.

Ad

Speaking at a press conference following the end of the second day's play in Manchester on Thursday, July 24, Thakur shared his views on the debate around the substitute rule in Test cricket. He commented:

"I think there is some discussion going on. I was reading it in the news. Whether that should come into play or not, right now I can't say much. But, if it happens, I would say it should happen after this WTC cycle. It shouldn't happen in the middle because a few series are being played as part of WTC. It would be unfair when it comes to the points table and qualifying for the finals, looking at the WTC cycle."
Ad
Ad

Pant, who retired hurt on 37 on Day 1 of the fourth Test at Old Trafford, came out to bat on Day 2 after Thakur's dismissal for 41. He went on to complete a crucial half-century before being dismissed for 54 by Jofra Archer.


"With the new ball, we could have been better" - Shardul Thakur on India's poor bowling effort on Day 2

Despite Pant's valiant knock, India were bowled out for a below par 358 in their first innings. In response, England made a brilliant start and were 225-2 at stumps after 46 overs. Openers Ben Duckett (94) and Zak Crawley (84) added 166 in 32 overs. Speaking about India's bowling effort, Thakur admitted:

Ad
"With the new ball, we could have been better. We were trying to hold it back, but runs kept flowing. It wasn't difficult for bowlers. We could have had much more patience in terms of bowling the channel, which we didn't. There were few deliveries, which we bowled well and there were few deliveries that just went for boundaries. We need to evaluate the kind of deliveries we need to stick to."
Ad

At stumps on Day 2 of the Manchester Test, Ollie Pope was batting on 20 and Joe Root on 11. England trail India by 133 runs, with eight wickets in hand.

Follow IPL Auction 2025 Live Updates, News & Biddings at Sportskeeda. Get the fastest updates on Mega-Auction and cricket news

Quick Links

Edited by Renin Wilben Albert
Sportskeeda logo
Close menu
WWE
WWE
NBA
NBA
NFL
NFL
MMA
MMA
Tennis
Tennis
NHL
NHL
Golf
Golf
MLB
MLB
Soccer
Soccer
F1
F1
WNBA
WNBA
down arrow icon
More
bell-icon Manage notifications