3 Manchester United players who need to prove themselves again this season

Manchester United v Arsenal - Premier League
Jose Mourinho is often criticized for his defensive tactics.

It is still questionable whether Manchester United are flourishing under Jose Mourinho or not.

A lot of United faithful firmly believe that Mourinho is the right man to restore the glory days at Old Trafford. Others, meanwhile, are baffled by his pragmatic approach and repeatedly end up criticizing his tactics.

A lot was expected from Mourinho in his second season in charge after he won the Europa League and the EFL Cup in his debut season. But it was a huge let-down for United as they crashed out from the Champions League in the knock out stages and lost the FA Cup final.

They did manage to finish second in the Premier League, but that was ludicrously distant from Manchester City.

It's not about the manager always; the players also fail to live up to the expectations sometimes. Despite that, the manager and fans keep their faith in them.

But of course, the players need to return the favor as well. Here we look at three such players who need to buckle down this season and repay the faith shown in them.


#3 Ander Herrera

Manchester City v Manchester United - Premier League
Ander Herrera hasn't performed up to the mark lately and faces a stiff competition

The signing of Nemanja Matic had a big impact on Ander Herrera. The competition for a place in the starting XI stiffened, limiting Herrera's game time.

Herrera was a regular starter before Matic’s arrival. In his debut season, Mourinho preferred him alongside Paul Pogba in the central midfield role - in a 4-2-3-1 system. Herrera was a consistent performer that season.

He played the most minutes of league football among the outfield players after Pogba and Antonio Valencia. However, when United signed Matic last summer, it was obvious that he would replace Herrera in the midfield.

Of course, the replacement did nothing wrong. On the contrary, it proved to be a masterstroke. Matic was like an immediate upgrade to Herrera.

The Spaniard found himself under the shadow of Matic, but he kept working hard and delivering brilliant performances whenever the team needed him.

No doubt his game time has reduced, as he started just 13 games last season as compared to the 27 he did the season before. United have added another member in the midfield department in Fred and thus, the fight for a place is even tougher.

This is the time for Herrera to make his mark and prove that he can still keep players like Eden Hazard at bay, and perform like he did in the match against Chelsea last year at Old Trafford.

The last season can be termed as arguably the worst for Herrera since his arrival from Athletic Bilbao back in 2014. Still, he is the kind of player who will always fit in Mourinho’s system - a proper box-to-box player who also loves to defend with his heart out.

Herrera has the opportunity to impress this season, and regain the trust of the manager. Only time will tell whether he succeeds in that.

#2 Victor Lindelof

Manchester United v Swansea City - Premier League
Victor Lindelof hasn't justified his price tag yet.

Victor Lindelof had a forgettable start in his first full appearance for the Red Devils, against Huddersfield last season. But there's no doubt that the Swede has improved since then.

However, he hasn’t performed convincingly enough to be the first choice at the center back position. Often players take some time to adapt in the Premier League, and it might be possible that Lindelof is going through that phase.

He made 13 starts in the league last season, yet he failed to establish himself among the first choice center-backs. That said, his performance improved over time as he was quite good in his outings in the second half of the last season. Moreover, Mourinho preferred him in the Champions League.

Unlike his counterpart Eric Bailly, Lindelof is yet to justify his hefty price tag (€ 35m plus add-ons). The Swedish international is the costliest defender that United have ever bought.

Bailly cost a bit lesser than him. But the Ivorian was an instant fit in the squad when he arrived at Old Trafford from Villareal and quickly became one of the fan favorites.

Lindelof is yet to accomplish those tags. So it is now up to him to establish a breakthrough season as tries to prove his worth to the club.

#1 Paul Pogba

France v Croatia - 2018 FIFA World Cup Russia Final
Paul Pogba has a statement to make with Manchester United after a glorious World Cup campaign

Some might agree, and some might beg to differ as to why Paul Pogba is on this list - especially considering he had an amazing World Cup winning campaign. But that is precisely where the question arises: why has Pogba been so strongly with France and not with United?

The answer to that question is not straightforward. After completing his two full seasons with his boyhood club, the French international is still struggling to keep up his form domestically. Sometimes he’s impressive and sometimes he seems too careless and clueless.

Perhaps the answer lies in the difference of the philosophy of the managers and the players surrounding him at the club and international level.

Whatever the reason may be, Pogba has often looked a shadow of his former (Juventus) self at United. He has a swagger when he’s in the French jersey but so far, he has failed to emulate that swagger in United colors.

Pogba possesses all the qualities of a first-class midfielder. With slight adjustments to his game and a little more adaptability, everything could fall into place for the young midfielder. But will it? The 2018-19 season will tell us one way or another.


Agree with our list? Disagree? Let us know in the comments below!

Quick Links