"Come on": The Masked Singer fans divided as Jenny McCarthy saves Gargoyle from elimination

Is Gargoyle an actor? (Image via Fox)
Is Gargoyle an actor? (Image via Fox)

The Masked Singer season 9 episode 4 aired on Fox on Wednesday, March 8 at 8 pm ET.

In the episode, three new singers, Gargoyle, Squirrel, and Wolf, joined the competition to win the winner's trophy. While Wolf was eliminated after the first round, Gargoyle and Squirrel reached the Battle Royale round.

Gargoyle sang Charlie Puth's One Call Away in the individual round and 3 Doors Down's Kryptonite in the second round.

He received the least number of votes and was about to be eliminated when judge Jenny McCarthy Wahlberg rang the 'Ding Dong Keep It On' Bell, which meant that the singer was saved from being unmasked and was not sent home. This feature can only be used once per group of new singers.

The Masked Singer fans were divided over the save option being used for Gargoyle. Some fans slammed Jenny McCarthy for ringing the bell as they wanted the singer's identity to be revealed.


The Masked Singer fans divided as Gargoyle is saved at the last moment

Some of the clues for Gargoyle's identity are:

  • Quote that said "From the time I was six, I pretty much knew I wanted to be a superhero. But while my peers all seemed to fly, I was always stuck on the sidelines"
  • A sticker on Jukebox saying "I Love LA"
  • Father as a motivational figure
  • Put on a cape to shock millions

Some The Masked Singer fans were curious about Gagoyle's identity and slammed Jenny for saving him at the last moment. They also expressed their dislike for the "saved by the bell" feature, which is new this season.

Others felt that Gargoyle was too good a singer to be sent home.


What happened on The Masked Singer season 9 episode 4?

Fox's description of the episode reads:

"Three new singers enter the game and celebrate their favourite iconic DC superheroes in costume; two singers are unmasked."

In the first round, Wolf sang a slow rendition of Break On Through (To the Other Side) by The Doors. His voice failed to impress the judges and he was unmasked afterwards. Wolf was revealed to be legendary singer Michael Bolton, who performed How am I supposed to live without you as his leaving encore performance.

The new character, Squirrel, impressed the audience with her cheerful voice. She sang P!nk's Try and 3 Doors Down's Kryptonite. She advanced to the next round, where she will perform against two new singers.


Tune into Fox to see if Gargoyle can qualify for the semi-finals or loses to another character on The Masked Singer. Fans can also stream the show on the network's website and Hulu one day after the television premiere. The winner of the series will get the Golden Mask trophy.

Quick Links

Edited by Prem Deshpande