The Traitors USA season 2: Who was killed in episode 5?

The Traitors USA
The Traitors USA's Latest Episode Sees Tamra Judge as the Unexpected Casualty in Season 2 (Image via Instagram/Tamrajudge)

The Traitors USA season 2 episode 5, which aired on January 25, 2024, saw the game's landscape undergo a dramatic shift with the calculated murder of Tamra Judge. Orchestrated by the "traitors" among the contestants, this murder was a strategic maneuver to gain an advantage.

The episode spotlighted traitors Phaedra Parks and Parvati Shallow's choice to target Tamra, aiming to capitalize on the chaos and damage trust among the "faithful." While the murder itself shocked, the ensuing impact on alliances and tactics also took center stage.


Game changes in The Traitors USA season 2 as Tamra Judge falls victim in episode 5

The Traitors USA season 2 episode 5 began with an intense confrontation between Phaedra Parks and Parvati Shallow, two players who had previously worked in unison. This clash set the tone for the episode, highlighting the growing tensions among the traitors. Phaedra weighed her options carefully when deciding who to eliminate next.

Choosing Tamra Judge as the target was strategically aimed at creating maximum confusion among the remaining faithful contestants. This decision was not made lightly, as it involved considering various factors and potential repercussions within the game.

The revelations of Tamra Judge's murder constituted a moment of climactic drama. The shocking announcement rattled players, fracturing precedent bonds and dynamics. The calculated selection of such a visible, involved contestant intentionally destabilized the faithful. In the aftermath, reactions erupted across the castle. Stunned competitors hurried to digest the maneuver’s significance, sending them scrambling to reconstruct theories and plans.

A significant aspect of this episode was the gameplay of Dan Gheesling, known for his strategic mind and ability to influence the game's direction. Dan's approach in this episode was marked by deliberate secrecy, keeping his thoughts and suspicions close to his chest. While effectively keeping him safe, this tactic also raised fears among other players.

The Traitors USA season 2 episode 5 also featured a mission challenge that added another layer of strategy to the game. The contestants were tasked with a bird-call mission, which required communication skills and teamwork. The stakes were high, as success in the mission meant winning a shield, a coveted item that offered protection from being murdered in the game.

Trishelle Cannatella and Bergie emerged victorious, securing the shield for themselves. This win was more than just a triumph in a challenge; it provided them with a significant strategic advantage, making them immune from the traitors' next move and altering the potential targets for the traitors.

The banishment round in The Traitors USA season 2 episode 5 was critical, marked by strategic plays and psychological warfare. In a clever move, Peter Weber spread misinformation about the shield's whereabouts, aiming to misdirect the traitors and protect the shielded players. This tactic added an element of intrigue to the game as players tried to outwit each other.

This round of The Traitors USA season 2 resulted in the banishment of Janelle Pierzina, a decision influenced by the alliances, suspicions, and Peter's misdirection. Janelle's exit from the game was a significant moment, as it reflected the culmination of the episode's strategic maneuvers and the shifting allegiances among the players.


The Traitors USA season 2 episode 5 reflected the unpredictable and strategic nature of the game. The murder of Tamra Judge, the mission challenge, the banishment round, and the return of Kate Chastain all contributed to an episode filled with suspense, strategy, and unexpected turns.

Obsessed with Crosswords, Wordle, and other word games? Take our quick survey and let us get to know you better!

Quick Links

App download animated image Get the free App now