Jamie Grachek's case - A detailed case overview

Jamie Grachek's case is a home invasion that resulted in the murder of her estranged husband, John T. Grachek, on Easter Sunday in 2013, in Riverside, Ohio. The initial custody dispute between the couple, who had been separated, turned fatal when Jamie hired two men to burglarize John's home.

The authorities later found the attack was not random but connected to other family feuds and financial stress.

John, a 45-year-old plumber, was shot in the struggle and died from his wounds. Jamie Grachek, who was in her early 30s at the time, insisted that the plan was an on-the-spot robbery for ready cash and not a plan to kill, as per Oxygen True Crime.

Two others were also indicted in the crime. Jamie pleaded guilty to lesser charges and is serving a prison term. The case has been reported in the mainstream media, providing information on the investigation and its effects on their families.

For viewers interested in a detailed narrative, the episode featuring this case on Oxygen's Snapped: Behind Bars, season 1, episode 6, is being re-aired on September 21, 2025.

---

Background of John and Jamie Grachek

Snapped: Behind Bars, season 1, episode 6 (Image via Unsplash/ @ Kenny Eliason)

Jamie Grachek grew up in a large family with limited finances, but described her childhood as happy, as reported by Oxygen True Crime. She left school in eighth grade after becoming pregnant and had five children by 2004, placing two for adoption. That year, she met John T. Grachek, a successful plumber who started his business in 1990.

John had been married before and had three children from that 13-year union before divorcing his first wife. He and Jamie Grachek married quickly, after just two or three months of dating, and John took on the role of stepfather to her three kids. The couple had two more children together, making a blended family, as per Oxygen. Their marriage lasted about 11 years but faced challenges.

According to the network, Jamie said John could sometimes be violent and vent his frustrations on the family. On the other hand, others close to him noted he was the main provider, feeling stressed as Jamie did not work and allegedly used drugs, a claim she denied.

By 2012, they had separated amid growing tensions. Jamie Grachek struggled financially, leading to the state removing the children from her home due to issues like a lack of electricity.

John sought custody to retrieve them from foster care. He started dating Nicole Price that summer, and they moved in together four months before the incident. The custody dispute intensified, with a court awarding John temporary custody one week before Easter 2013. A final hearing was set for shortly after, according to Oxygen.

---

Events leading to the crime

John was being harassed by Jamie Grachek (Image via Unsplash/ @ Lance Reis)

In the months before the 2013 incident, the separation between Jamie and John grew hostile. Jamie reportedly harassed John, leading him to change his phone number and block her on social media. As reported by Oxygen, Nicole Price, John's girlfriend, described Jamie's actions as erratic, such as driving onto their lawn at night and damaging the grass. Jamie later called this behavior "childish and dumb."

Jamie, in turn, claimed John stalked her by sitting in her driveway early mornings. The custody battle added fuel, with witnesses at a court hearing reporting Jamie's threat to kill John if he gained custody, as per Oxygen. Financial strain played a role in Jamie's actions as she needed money quickly after the separation.

On Easter night, around 9 p.m., she received a call from Jacob Gipson, an acquaintance, discussing ways to get cash. They first considered robbing a local drug dealer, but abandoned that idea. Under the influence of Xanax, Jamie Grachek suggested targeting John, believing he might have money at home.

She recruited Gary Webb, a 29-year-old she did not know well, through Gipson. Text messages later revealed a possible romantic link between Jamie and Gipson, though she denies it today.

The group proceeded with the plan, viewing it as a simple robbery. No prior drug connections were found in John's background, countering later claims by accomplices, according to Oxygen.

---

The night of the murder

John was shot by Gary Webb (Image via Unsplash/ @ Max Kleinen)

On March 31, 2013, around 10:30 p.m., John Grachek was at home on Rosegarden Court with Nicole Price. John was relaxing on the couch while Nicole was in the kitchen. A knock at the door prompted Nicole to answer, where she faced an armed man later identified as Gary Webb, as per Oxygen. John rushed in, leading to a brief struggle. Shots were fired, hitting John in the chest and thigh.

Nicole hid from the attackers and called 911, capturing sounds of multiple gunshots. John managed to flee inside briefly but collapsed in the front yard.

Neighbors saw two men, Webb and Jacob Gipson, running to a parked car driven by Jamie Grachek. Police spotted the speeding vehicle matching descriptions and pulled it over, finding Jamie driving with Webb and Gipson inside, according to Oxygen.

Nicole identified Webb as the shooter at the scene. John was still alive when authorities arrived, but died en route to the hospital. No money or drugs were taken from the home, and John's history showed no involvement in drug dealing. The incident was initially reported as a home invasion robbery, but was linked back to the custody issues.

---

Investigation, trial, and aftermath

Jamie Grachek was sentenced to 21 years in prison (Image via Getty)

Police interrogated the suspects immediately after the stop. Webb claimed they went to buy heroin, and the gun fired accidentally during a fight, but no evidence supported this.

Gipson blamed Webb, saying the shot occurred in a scuffle. Investigators uncovered texts showing the robbery plan and a possible romance between Jamie and Gipson. Jamie admitted to suggesting the robbery but denied wanting John dead, as per Oxygen.

In April 2013, a grand jury indicted Jamie on complicity to commit murder, aggravated burglary, aggravated robbery, and felonious assault, each with firearm specifications. Webb and Gipson faced similar charges, plus murder.

By late 2014, all pleaded guilty. Jamie was convicted of involuntary manslaughter, complicity to aggravated robbery, and aggravated burglary, receiving a flat 21-year sentence without good-time credit. Webb got 18 years to life, Gipson 15 years to life.

Jamie Grachek's children were placed with relatives. From prison, she expressed remorse, saying on Snapped: Behind Bars:

"I have a lot of regrets... I made a mistake."

She plans to open a women's shelter upon release around 2035.

---

Snapped: Behind Bars, season 1, episode 6, will re-air on Oxygen on September 21, 2025.