5 current female WWE stars who are a perfect fit for Sister Abigail

In his years in WWE, Bray Wyatt has been somewhat of a chameleon. He has portrayed different personas, including Husky Harris, cult leader Bray Wyatt and, more recently, The Fiend. In his time as the figurehead of the Wyatt Family, Bray talked about Sister Abigail multiple times, spinning different theories as to whether she is real, or an alter ego.

The idea of Sister Abigail was brought to the forefront during late 2017 when Bray suggested that the mysterious entity wanted to meet Finn Balor's Demon. However, during a conflict with Randy Orton, the Wyatt Family Compound (where the grave of Sister Abigail lay) was burned to the ground, supposedly destroying what was left of her.

Since the birth of The Fiend, we have again had hints towards Sister Abigail. One of the characters in the Firefly Fun House is Abby the Witch, a clear nod to her. Even more recently, we have had possibly the biggest call back to the character yet. Alexa Bliss appeared dressed as the Sister Abigail during the Swamp Fight between Bray Wyatt and Braun Strowman at Extreme Rules.

The brief appearance sparked much debate online, with fans wondering whether Alexa Bliss was now Sister Abigail, or whether she was taking on the form to taunt Strowman. However, it's interesting to think about who could portray her.

If Paige was still active, she could have been an excellent choice, and NXT's Scarlett has the skills to pull it off, but it would be foolish to tear her away from Karrion Kross right now.

Let's take a look at which superstars would be likely candidates to become Sister Abigail, if WWE do decide to go that route.

---

#5 Nikki Cross

Nikki Cross

In her time in NXT, Nikki Cross portrayed a wily, unstable character. She was the stand-out member of the stable SAnitY and often entertained the crowds with her unhinged persona and crazy promo skills, going from kooky to scary in the space of seconds.

Since Cross made her debut on SmackDown in 2018, she has mellowed somewhat. Nikki Cross has been partnered with Alexa Bliss from her move to RAW in 2019, and the pair have held the tag team championships twice. During Nikki's time on RAW and SmackDown, her character has turned in the direction of silly and excitable, a far cry from the former "Twisted Sister" of NXT.

In recent weeks, a break up between Bliss and Cross has been hinted at, with the pair facing off over a shot at Bayley's SmackDown Women's Championship. During the recent match between them, the pair seemed somewhat conflicted, arguing during some moments. Nikki even pushed Alexa over before the match, fuelling more rumors of a split between them both.

Nikki's time in NXT proved that she had what it takes to represent a character like Sister Abigail. As the relationship between Nikki Cross and Alexa Bliss seems to be coming to a close, maybe becoming the right-hand woman to Bray Wyatt could be Nikki's next move?

#4 Ember Moon

Ember Moon as Sister Abigail?

Ember Moon has been missing from our screens after being injured in Autumn last year. Leading up into her injury, Ember was five matches deep into an unfortunate losing streak. Around this time, Ember's character has changed from a fierce force to be reckoned with, who struck fear into her opponents, into a bookworm and gamer who was subject to bullying from Mandy Rose and Sonya.

During her time in NXT, Ember proved that she had the promise to be a star in the making, and she has had amazing matches with the likes of Shayna Baszler, Asuka, and Nikki Cross. Ember Moon is a mighty in-ring contender with a distinctive move-set that makes her feel like a one-off in comparison to other stars today.

Upon the return of Moon, a much-needed character refresh could prove beneficial to her, and coming back as Sister Abigail could be perfect. She already thrives performing in an ethereal, mysterious aesthetic, and has been showing us since her NXT days what a unique in-ring talent she is. This could make her a great candidate to become Sister Abigail.

#3 Isla Dawn

Isla Dawn

Currently working on NXT UK, Isla Dawn would be a great candidate to become Sister Abigail. Isla debuted during the 2018 Mae Young classic, and although quickly eliminated, she proved a memorable contender.

Isla was encouraged to start wrestling by NXT star Killian Dain, who watched her in a play and was impressed by her theatrical skills. He also later trained her with the help of his wife Nikki Cross. Coincidentally, these acting skills are a reason why she would shine in the role of Sister Abigail alongside Bray Wyatt. Wyatt himself is probably one of the strongest actors in WWE and can shape-shift between three different personalities.

In her promos, Isla Dawn is described as a "white witch" and she embodies that in her overall wrestling performance. The look that Isla currently has is already halfway to what we could expect from Sister Abigail – black jackets reminiscent of a witches' cloak, dark lipstick, and flowing hair. It is clear that Isla also has an understanding of how to portray someone as influential as Sister Abigail, as she has previously stated that she gets her inspiration from strong women.

This is apparent as she comes across as strong yet feminine, a great fit for the portrayal of the undead sister of Bray Wyatt.

#2 Kayden Carter

Could Kayden Carter work as Sister Abigail?

Like Isla Dawn, Kayden Carter also made her WWE debut in the 2018 Mae Young Classic, defeating two of her competitors. Kayden has teamed up with many big NXT names, including Mia Yim and Tegan Nox, but has unfortunately been on a losing streak since March.

Despite her current losing streak, Kayden has been shown to have a strong skill set, holding her own against huge talents such as Charlotte Flair. She has the ability to perfectly execute moves such as the crucifix driver against her foes, combined with her quick, sharp athleticism. Kayden is a very talented member of the NXT roster and is ready to make the next move in her wrestling career.

As well as this, Kayden has one of the most unique looks on the NXT roster, and certainly would not be out of place in the Wyatt Family Compound as Sister Abigail with her colored dreads and striking tattoos. Kayden also commands attention for her use of contact lenses in a similar manner to Ember Moon, who is also on this list. Kayden may not seem an obvious choice to fit the bill as Sister Abigail, but she certainly has the skills, look, and aura to shine in the role.

#1 Liv Morgan

Liv Morgan has the look to pull off Sister Abigail

A name that always seems to appear when discussing Sister Abigail is former Riott Squad member Liv Morgan. Back in 2019, Liv lost to Charlotte Flair and after the match, she snatched a headset from the commentary table and declared that when she was coming back, she was going to be “real”.

After this, rumors circled that Liv was going to return as a member of the Firefly Fun House, which was further fueled by Bray Wyatt featuring a blonde-haired, blue-eyed doll in his video segments.

Leading up to the return of Liv, video packages were shown on RAW. In these videos, she discussed how she was controlled during her time in the Riott Squad, and described herself as “anything but typical”. Liv then indeed returned with a new look, but not how fans were expecting. She appeared on a late December episode of RAW to interrupt the wedding between Bobby Lashley and Lana, claiming to have been in love with the latter. The storyline was quickly binned amid fan criticism.

This year, Liv has indeed changed her look to become more gothic, with black outfits and grey hair, which has made her stand out more against the rest of the women’s roster. The look that Liv has been sporting this year is more dark and mysterious in the vein of what we would expect from Sister Abigail. Liv Morgan is a very charismatic performer, who has the potential to be a huge star in the WWE. Playing Sister Abigail could undoubtedly catapult her to the next level.