#3 Shelton Benjamin

Shelton Benjamin was a household name in WWE during his initial run in the company. He had some incredible matches against the likes of Chris Jericho, Triple H, and Kurt Angle. He even won multiple titles for his exploits including the Intercontinental Championship, the United States Championship, and the WWE Tag Team Championship.
His second stint with WWE though has been largely unsatisfactory. Benjamin was paired with Chad Gable upon his return in 2017 and the duo seemed to be making a mark in the tag division, getting multiple shots at the SmackDown Tag Team Championships in the process which they failed to make use of.
Did Goldberg ruin Bray Wyatt's career? - Watch Now!
The two were split following WrestleMania 34 and while Roman Reigns' career has only soared during all this while, Benjamin's has continued to spiral down. Given that Shelton Benjamin is only making sporadic appearances these days, he could be used once in a while against Reigns sometime down the future but it would likely be a squash match.
In the ideal setup though, Benjamin and Reigns have the capacity to blow the roof off the arena if allowed to put up a match to the best of their abilities.
One wrong move ended Big E's career - Watch Here!