COOKIE CONSENT
Create
Notifications
Favorites Edit

The refereeing decisions in EPL this season

Simon
SENIOR ANALYST
Stats
1.44K   //    12 Dec 2012, 10:28 IST

As we did last season, this is a list of all the big incorrect refereeing decisions we have judged this season broken down into teams, for and against. We have covered every single Premier League game so far, and we’re the only site available that offers such a comprehensive service, so if you think we’ve got something wrong drop us a comment, but remember how much time and effort goes into making this work.

Arsenal

For
Jermaine Pennant penalty shout not awarded against Stoke.
Luis Suarez penalty shout not awarded against Liverpool.
Sergio Aguero penalty shout not awarded against Man City.
Arteta goal awarded despite being offside against QPR.
Penalty awarded for handball incorrectly against Fulham.
Pienaar penalty shout not awarded against Everton.

Against
Wilkinson handball in area, no penalty or red card awarded against Stoke (2 decisions)

Aston Villa

For
Brad Guzan awarded a yellow rather than a red card for penalty decision against Southampton.
Albrighton handball in area not awarded as a penalty against West Brom.
Penalty shout not awarded against Norwich.
Herd not shown second yellow for late tackle against Norwich.

Against
Penalty awarded for handball in area against Weimann against Man City.

Chelsea

For
Torres goal awarded despite being offside against Reading.
David Luiz tackle on Walters, no red shown against Stoke.
Torres not shown straight red for high tackle on Cleverley against Man Utd.

Against
John Terry penalty shout not awarded against QPR.
Eden Hazard penalty shout not awarded against QPR.
Oscar penalty shout not awarded against Stoke.
Torres shown second yellow incorrectly for diving against Man Utd.
Hernandez goal awarded despite being offside against Man Utd.
Suarez push on Ramires in build up to goal against Liverpool.
Moses penalty shout not awarded against West Brom.
Cole goal awarded despite foul on Ivanovic against West Ham.

Everton

For
Victor Anichebe goal given despite handball in build up from Fellaini against Swansea.
Hoilett penalty shout not awarded against QPR.
Throw in incorrectly awarded in build up to Liverpool equaliser.
Suarez goal incorrectly ruled out for offside against Liverpool.

Against
Victor Anichebe shot over line not awarded against Newcastle.
Marouane Fellaini goal incorrectly ruled out for offside against Newcastle.
Kone goal allowed despite being offside against Wigan.
Jelavic penalty shout #1 not awarded against Wigan.
Jelavic penalty shout #2 not awarded against Wigan.
Pienaar penalty second yellow incorrectly awarded against QPR.
Jelavic penalty shout not awarded against QPR.
Suarez not shown red card for tackle on Distin against Livepool.
Morrison handball in area not awarded as a penalty against Reading.
Free kick which led to goal incorrectly awarded against Norwich.
Pienaar penalty shout not awarded against Arsenal.

Fulham

For
Andy Carroll penalty shout not awarded against West Ham.
Riise penalty incorrectly awarded against Man City.
Carlos Tevez penalty shout not awarded against Man City.
Goal incorrectly disallowed for foul on Schwarzer against Southampton.

Against
Penalty awarded for handball incorrectly against Arsenal.

Liverpool

For
Suarez not shown red card for tackle on Distin against Everton.
Suarez push on Ramires in build up to goal against Chelsea.
Suarez not shown red card for stamp on Wigan player.
Throw in incorrectly awarded to Liverpool in build up to goal against Wigan.
Agger goal awarded despite being offside against Southampton.

Against
Glen Johnson penalty shout not awarded against Man City.
Luis Suarez penalty shout not awarded against Arsenal.
Antonio Valencia penalty incorrectly awarded against Man Utd.
Luis Suarez penalty shout not awarded against Norwich.
Huth stamp on Suarez no red card awarded against Stoke.
Throw in incorrectly awarded in build up to Everton equaliser.
Suarez goal incorrectly ruled out for offside against Everton.
Suarez penalty shout not awarded against Newcastle.
Free kick awarded incorrectly that led to goal against Spurs.
Suarez penalty shout not awarded against Spurs.
Suarez penalty shout not awarded against Southampton.

Manchester City

For
Tevez goal awarded despite being offside against Southampton.
Glen Johnson penalty shout not awarded against Liveprool.
Free kick incorrectly awarded for equaliser against Stoke.
Nolan goal incorrectly ruled out for offside against West Ham.
Adebayor penalty shout not awarded against Spurs.
Penalty awarded for Weimann handball in area incorrectly against Aston Villa.

Against
Peter Crouch goal awarded despite handball against Stoke.
Andy Wilkinson elbow on Balotelli no red card awarded against Stoke.
Sergio Aguero penalty shout not awarded against Arsenal.
Riise penalty incorrectly awarded against Fulham.
Carlos Tevez penalty shout not awarded against Fulham.
Gallas handball in area not awarded as a penalty against Spurs.
Zabaleta penalty shout not awarded against Spurs.

Manchester United

For
Danny Welbeck penalty incorrectly awarded against Wigan.
Antonio Valencia penalty incorrectly awarded against Liverpool.
Cisse penalty shout not awarded against Newcastle.
Van Persie elbow no red card awarded against Newcastle.
Torres shown second yellow incorrectly for diving against Chelsea.
Hernandez goal awarded despite being offside against Chelsea.

Against
Nani penalty shout not awarded against Spurs.
Sandro handball in area not awarded as a penalty against Spurs.
Tiote tackle on Cleverley no red card awarded against Newcastle.
Torres not shown straight red for high tackle on Cleverley against Chelsea.
Van Persie shot over line not awarded as a goal against Reading.

Newcastle United

For
Victor Anichebe shot over line not awarded against Everton.
Marouane Fellaini goal incorrectly ruled out for offside against Everton.
Tiote tackle on Cleverley no red card given against Man Utd.
Suarez penalty shout not awarded against Liverpool.

Against
Cisse penalty shout not awarded against Man Utd.
Van Persie elbow no red card awarded against Man Utd.

Norwich City

For
Huddlestone red card incorrectly awarded against Spurs.
Luis Suarez penalty shout not awarded against Liverpool.
Free kick which led to goal incorrectly awarded against Stoke.
Free kick which led to goal incorrectly awarded against Everton.

Against
Robert Green handball outside area, no free kick or card awarded against QPR.
Morrison penalty shout not awarded against Spurs.
Bobby Zamora penalty not retaken despite encroachment against QPR.
Penalty shout not awarded against Aston Villa.
Herd not shown second yellow for late tackle against Aston Villa.
Free kick incorrectly awarded in build up to goal against Southampton.

Queens Park Rangers

For
Robert Green handball outside area, no free kick or card awarded against Norwich.
Bobby Zamora penalty not retaken despite encroachment against Norwich.
John Terry penalty shout not awarded against Chelsea.
Eden Hazard penalty shout not awarded against Chelsea.
Sigurdsson penalty shout not awarded against Spurs.
Pienaar second yellow incorrectly awarded against Everton.
Jelavic penalty shout not awarded against Everton.

Against
Hoilett penalty shout not awarded against Everton.
Arteta foal awarded despite being offside against Arsenal.
Penalty shout not awarded against Reading.

Reading

For
Penalty shout not awarded against QPR.
Morrison handball in area not awarded as a penalty against Everton.
Free kick incorrectly awarded leading to goal against Wigan.
Di Santo goal incorrectly ruled out for offside against Wigan.
Van Persie shot over line not awarded as a goal against Man Utd.

Against
Torres goal awarded despite being offside against Chelsea.
Kyle Walker handball in area not awarded as a penalty against Spurs.
Tabb penalty shout not awarded against Wigan.

Southampton

For
Suarez penalty shout not awarded against Liverpool.
Free kick incorrectly awarded in build up to goal against Norwich.

Against
Tevez goal awarded despite being offside against Man City
Brad Guzan awarded a yellow rather than a red card for penalty decision against Aston Villa.
Goal incorrectly disallowed for foul on Schwarzer against Fulham.
Lallana penalty shout not awarded against Swansea.
Agger goal awarded despite being offside against Liverpool.

Stoke City

For
Wilkinson handball in area, no penalty or red carded awarded against Arsenal (2 decisions)
Peter Crouch goal awarded despite handball against Man City.
Andy Wilkinson elbow on Balotelli no red card awarded against Man City.
Oscar penalty shout not awarded against Chelsea.
Huth stamp on Suarez no red card awarded against Liverpool.

Against
Jermaine Pennant penalty shout not awarded against Arsenal.
Free kick incorrectly awarded for Man City equaliser.
David Luiz tackle on Walters, no red shown against Chelsea.
Free kick which led to goal incorrectly awarded against Norwich.

Sunderland

For
Wayne Routledge penalty shout not awarded against Swansea.
Gomez red card incorrectly awarded against Wigan.
Larsson tackle on Kone no red card awarded against Wigan.

Against
Stephen Fletcher penalty shout not awarded against Swansea.
Chico tackle on James McClean, no red awarded against Swanea.
Ridgewell penalty awarded incorrectly against West Brom.

Swansea City

For
Stephen Fletcher penalty shout not awarded against Sunderland.
Chico tackle on James McClean, no red awarded against Sunderland.
Kone goal incorrectly ruled out for offside against Wigan.
Lallana penalty shout not awarded against Southampton.

Against
Wayne Routledge penalty shout not awarded against Sunderland.
Victor Anichebe goal given despite handball in build up from Fellaini against Everton.

Tottenham Hotspur

For
Morrison penalty shout not awarded against Norwich.
Kyle Walker handball in area not awarded as a penalty against Reading.
Nani penalty shout not awarded against Man Utd.
Sandro handball in area not awarded as a penalty against Man Utd.
Gallas handball in area not awarded as a penalty against Man City.
Zabaleta penalty shout not awarded against Man City.
Free kick awarded incorrectly that led to goal against Liverpool.
Suarez penalty shout not awarded against Liveprool.

Against
Huddlestone red card incorrectly awarded against Norwich.
Sigurdsson penalty shout not awarded against QPR.
Adebayor penalty shout not awarded against Man City.

West Bromwich Albion

For
Moses penalty shout not awarded against Chelsea.
Ridgewell penalty awarded incorrectly against Sunderland.

Against
Albrighton handball in area not awarded as a penalty against Aston Villa.

West Ham United

For
Cole goal awarded despite foul on Ivanovic against Chelsea.

Against
Andy Carroll penalty shout not awarded against Fulham.
Nolan goal incorrectly ruled out for offside against Man City.

Wigan Athletic

For
Kone goal allowed despite being offside against Everton.
Jelavic penalty shout #1 not awarded against Everton.
Jelavic penalty shout #2 not awarded against Everton.
Tabb penalty shout not awarded against Reading.

Against
Danny Welbeck penalty incorrectly awarded against Man Utd.
Gomez red card incorrectly awarded against Sunderland.
Larsson tackle on Kone no red card awarded against Sunderland.
Kone goal incorrectly ruled out for offside against Swansea.
Suarez not shown red card for stamp on Wigan player.
Throw in incorrectly awarded to Liverpool in build up to goal.
Free kick incorrectly awarded leading to Reading goal.
Di Santo goal incorrectly ruled out for offside against Reading.

Topics you might be interested in:
Simon
SENIOR ANALYST
Fetching more content...