| Ring name | Real name |
| Adam Page | Stevie Woltz |
| Alex Shelly | Patrick Martin |
| Beer City Bruiser | Matthew Dearth |
| Beretta | Greg Marasciulo |
| Brian Milonas | Unknown |
| B.J. Whitmer | Benjamin Whitmer |
| Bully Ray | Mark LoMonaco |
| Caprice Coleman | Caprice Coleman |
| Cheeseburger | Brandel Littlejohn |
| Chris Sabin | Joshua Harter |
| Christopher Daniels | Daniel Covell |
| Chuckie T. | Dustin Howard |
| Cody | Cody Runnels Rhodes |
| Colt Cabana | Scott Colton |
| Dalton Castle | Brett Giehl |
| Delirious | Hunter Johnson |
| Eli Isom | Elijah Isom |
| Flip Gordon | Travis Lopes Jr. |
| Frankie Kazarian | Frank Gerdelman |
| Jay Briscoe | Jamin Pugh |
| Jay Lethal | Jamar Shipman |
| Jay White | Jay White |
| Jonathan Gresham | Jonathan Gresham |
| Josh Woods | Joshua Woods |
| Kenny King | Kenny Layne |
| LSG | Leon St. Giovanni |
| Mark Briscoe | Mark Pugh |
| Marty Scurll | Martin Scurll |
| Matt Jackson | Matthew Massie |
| Matt Taven | Matthew Marinelli |
| Nana | Nana Bandoh |
| Nick Jackson | Nicholas Massie |
| Punishment Martinez | Luis Martínez |
| Rhett Titus | Everett Titus |
| Rocky Romero | John Rivera |
| Scorpio Sky | Schulyer Andrews |
| Shaheem Ali | Shaheem Harper |
| Shane Taylor | Michael Taris |
| Silas Young | Caleb DeWall |
| The Boys | Brandon Tate and Brent Tate |
| TK O'Ryan | Stephen Tkowski |
| Vinny Marseglia | Vincent Marseglia |
| Will Ferrara | William Ferrara |
| Will Ospreay | William Ospreay |
| Ring name | Real name |
| Brandi Rhodes | Brandi Rhodes |
| Gabby Ortiz | Gabriella Belpre |
| Jenny Rose | Jenny Rose |
| Jessie Brooks | Unknown |
| Karen Q | Karen Yu |
| Kelly Klein | Kelly Klein |
| Madison Rayne | Ashley Lomberger |
| Mandy Leon | Amanda Leon |
| Stella Grey | Unknown |
| Sumie Sakai | Sumie Sakai |
| Tenille Dashwood | Tenille Dashwood |
