Who were voted as American Idol season 23's Top 3? Details explored

American Idol season 23 revealed its Top 3 contestants in the latest episode that aired on May 12, 2025. Titled Disney Night No. 2, the episode saw the Top 5 artists return to the stage to sing for the audience watching, hoping to earn their votes and a seat in the next phase.

While all artists tried, it was Jamal Roberts, John Foster, and Breanna Nix who were voted into the Top 3. With their entry into the last stage of the contest, Slater Nalley and Thunderstorm Artis were removed from the competition.

The Top 3 singers were guided by guest mentor Lin-Manuel Miranda as they delivered noteworthy renditions of popular Disney songs, earning praise from the audience and panelists alike.

---

Which songs did the Top 3 singers perform on American Idol season 23 episode 18?

1) Jamal Roberts

Jamal Roberts, a 27-year-old P.E. teacher from Meridian, Mississippi, first appeared on stage with his take on Ain't No Mountain High Enough from Remember the Titans. The judges appreciated his performance. However, Carrie Underwood said he "missed an opportunity to move around and entertain."

"We know you have that in you. Let's go!" she added.

Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan, on the other hand, gave positive reactions, appreciating the American Idol singer's ability to consistently deliver "soulful" acts.

He returned to the stage later that night and presented the experts with his rendition of the title track from Beauty and the Beast. Lionel and Luke gave him a standing ovation and complimented him for connecting with the crowd.

"Jamal, let's win this thing!" Luke exclaimed.

To vote for Jamal, viewers can text 12 to 21523.

---

2) Breanna Nix

Breanna Nix, a 25-year-old Texan, sang This Will Be (An Everlasting Love) from The Parent Trap during her first performance on American Idol's second sitting of Disney Night. While reviewing her act, the judges gave mixed reactions, as Carrie said:

"The first half, I felt like you were a little bit unsure. Your next performance, just have fun."

Lionel expressed a similar sentiment, urging Breanna not to let the nerves overwhelm her. Luke, on the other hand, commended her vibe and delivery.

For her second act, the American Idol contestant sang You'll Be in My Heart from Tarzan. While sharing her judgment on Breanna's act, Carrie said:

"You brought us into your family, and it was such a sweet moment. You have been so solid throughout this entire competition."

Meanwhile, Luke added that her presence was "so strong."

To vote for Breanna, viewers can text 9 to 21523.

---

3) John Foster

John Foster stepped on the American Idol stage to sing The Bare Necessities from The Jungle Book for his first act. Carrie was pleasantly surprised by how the 18-year-old singer took a "fun song" and gave it his own twist. Lionel thought John had "likability," which he believed connected viewers with him.

"You've got 'em right where you want 'em. You've got a thing, you've got a look, you've got a sound," Luke remarked.

When John returned later that night for his second act, he sang Rainbow Connection from The Muppets. His rendition compelled Carrie to mention:

"I love that you're standing here right now proving me right. If you ain't real careful, you might just win this whole thing."

Lionel and Luke were equally positive about John's act, applauding his vocal notes and authenticity.

To vote for John, viewers can text 13 to 21523.

---

Stream American Idol episodes on Hulu.