5 horrifying details about Rachael Anderson's murder 

In April of 2010, Rachael Anderson, the mother of four, age 40, went missing in Moscow, Idaho, under mysterious conditions. She had just ended a relationship with her estranged husband, Charles Capone, a Moscow mechanic. When she failed to answer calls from her children, an alarm was immediately raised, and her disappearance created one of Latah County's most terrifying criminal cases.

Anderson's body has never been discovered despite thorough searches. What followed was a tale of treachery, a murder plot, and a trial based largely on circumstantial evidence and testimony.

The case gained renewed attention with Dateline: Secrets Uncovered, season 9, episode 27, which re-aired on August 22, 2025, on Oxygen.

---

Five horrifying details about Rachael Anderson’s murder

1. A deadly pact between friends

Dateline: Secrets Uncovered (Image via Unsplash/ @ Markus Spiske)

One of the revelations from the case was the pact between Charles Capone and his friend David Stone. According to court documents and testimony, the two men conspired to kill each other’s wives if necessary, a chilling agreement that eventually ensnared Rachael Anderson.

Investigators learned about this arrangement after Stone cooperated with authorities. He explained that the pact was meant as a “mutual assurance” that neither man would be alone in carrying out such a crime.

Stone later admitted that he helped Capone subdue Anderson and dispose of her body. His confession gave prosecutors critical insight into the crime’s planning and execution. The existence of such a pact illustrated that the crime was premeditated, transforming what could have been seen as a domestic dispute into a calculated conspiracy, according to CBS News.

---

2. Rachael Anderson was allegedly drugged before her death

Stone revealed that Anderson was drugged before she died (Image via Unsplash/ @ Myriam Zilles)

Stone’s testimony also revealed harrowing details about Anderson’s final moments. According to him, Anderson was allegedly drugged before being strangled to death. While the exact method remains unclear, this suggests she was rendered defenseless before her death. Such a revelation highlighted how calculated the attack was, ensuring she could not resist or call for help.

Despite this confession, no physical evidence, like toxicology results or DNA, was recovered. Since Anderson’s body has never been found, investigators were unable to verify Stone’s claims. Nonetheless, prosecutors used his statements to piece together a possible sequence of events. Jurors found the evidence credible enough to convict Capone, according to KHQ Local News.

---

3. Capone’s jailhouse confession

Capone admitted to killing Anderson to Brent Glass in jail(Image via Unsplash/ @ Michele Wales)

While awaiting trial, Charles Capone allegedly confessed to another inmate, Brent Glass. According to Glass’s testimony, Capone admitted to killing Rachael Anderson and burying her body so deeply that it would never be found. Prosecutors highlighted this statement during the trial, using it to reinforce the theory that Capone had intentionally hidden Rachael Anderson’s remains to avoid detection.

This jailhouse confession, while not backed by physical evidence, aligned with the rest of the state’s circumstantial case. Glass testified that Capone described the killing in detail and showed no remorse. The inmate’s account further convinced jurors that Capone was responsible for Anderson’s disappearance.

The fact that Capone himself hinted at disposing of the body in a manner that would prevent recovery added weight to the prosecution’s argument. According to CBS News, Anderson was not simply missing; she had been murdered.

---

4. Extensive searches yielded nothing

Rachael Anderson's body was not found (Image via Unsplash/ @ Dmitrii E.)

The authorities conducted several searches of the Snake River and the surrounding backcountry in hopes of finding Anderson's remains. Dive teams, cadaver canines, and helicopters were all used, but nothing turned up.

Investigators even carried out an unusual experiment, wrapping a deer in clothing similar to what Anderson was reportedly wearing and submerging it in the river to observe how a body would float. Each search ultimately ended in disappointment.

The absence of physical evidence posed as the biggest hurdle for prosecutors. They had to make their case entirely based on testimony, circumstantial evidence, and taped communications among suspects. The fact that no sign of Anderson has ever been found makes the case haunting for her family, who are still short of closure, as reported by KSL/AP News.

---

5. Convictions without Rachael Anderson's body

Charles was sentenced to life in prison without parole(Image via Unsplash/ @ Jaclyn Baxter)

Despite the absence of Rachael Anderson’s body, both Capone and Stone were charged with murder in May 2013. Capone went to trial in September 2014, where jurors heard weeks of testimony from Stone, investigators, and jailhouse witnesses.

He was found guilty of first-degree murder, conspiracy, and failure to report a death. In January 2015, he was sentenced to life in prison without parole, and his appeals were later denied.

Stone, on the other hand, took a plea deal. He pleaded guilty to lesser charges, including failure to report a death, and served three years in prison before being released. His cooperation was crucial in securing Capone’s conviction.

The case became a prime example of a successful “no-body” prosecution, where testimony and circumstantial evidence were enough to achieve justice. Rachael Anderson’s children and relatives are still left without closure regarding the location of her remains, according to KHQ Local News.

---

Stay tuned for more news and updates.