Top 7 Women's Superstars to play the role of Sister Abigail                                                         

Enter cap
Will the mystery finally be revealed?

Windham Rotunda is someone who has not necessarily been dealt the best hand during his WWE career. With that being said, it's hard to complain when you are a former WWE Champion and one of the company's top Superstars. However, things haven't always been that way. In fact, things were pretty difficult in the beginning for the third-generation Superstar.

After suffering through the Husky Harris era, Rotunda went back the drawing board and essentially, reinvented himself completely. This was where Bray Wyatt was born.

As Bray Wyatt evolved and The Wyatt Family was built around him, things began to truly look up. However, just as quickly as things got off to a great start, things have now seemingly hit a brick wall.

Bray is now at a very pivotal point in his career. While he is still a well-respected Superstar, things have sort of grown stale for "The Eater of Worlds" and at this point, his career is in desperate need of some kind of jolt, so to speak. That jolt could very well be by revealing the identity of Sister Abigail.


#7 Shayna Baszler

Enter cap
This one could get interesting...

Never before have wrestling fans seen someone quite like Shayna Baszler. She comes into the company with the look, the athletic ability, and the drive to be a top-tier star. However, she lacks one fundamental quality... experience.

Ladies and gentlemen of the WWE Universe, say hello to Shayna Baszler. She holds a brown belt in Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu and she can probably pound your head off of your shoulders. Needless to say, she is a legit bad-ass. Shayna comes to NXT via the Mae Young Classic and although her wrestling experience is minimal, she does seem to have learned a lot during her short time in the ring.

Shayna is probably best known by WWE fans as one of the members of the infamous Four Horsewomen, along with Ronda Rousey.

Shayna is in an interesting spot as a newly signed NXT star. Not only does she lack much in-ring experience, but she's also 37 years of age. These two factors may be a contributing factor as far as consideration for playing the role of Sister Abigail, as WWE officials may very well use these factors and move her up for the role.

Considering the role will not likely require much in-ring work, other than simple storyline acting and selling, it seems perfectly suited for her.

#6 Ember Moon

Enter capti
There's a huge future in store for this star!

When she was on the indie scene, she was known better as Athena, which is where she really made her mark and ultimately where WWE officials noticed her and gained interest. Since arriving in NXT, Ember Moon has broken through to become a premier star, on the verge of becoming the NXT Women's Champion.

Even after suffering an unfortunate shoulder injury, she was still able to come back and compete at the same high level that she had previously shown the NXT faithful she was capable of.

Whoever assumes the role of Sister Abigail must be strong, devious and someone demented when necessary. Ember Moon has proved throughout her career that she is more than capable of handling such a role.

#5 Leva Bates (Blue Pants)

n
Where did she go?

Contrary to what many fans may think, "Blue Pants" was never actually under a WWE contract. This was the reason why it was so easy for her to keep a full alternate schedule.

Leva Bates, also known as "Blue Pants" is someone who became an accidental sensation. I can still remember watching NXT and hearing the fans in attendance start the first chant "Blue Pants."

Since her last stint with NXT, Leva has kept a full schedule, mostly wrestling in full cosplay wherever she goes. In fact, the cosplay is probably one of her best-kept secrets, which would certainly help her in performing the Abigail role, if she were to be considered.

#4 Nikki Cross

Ente
Nikki Cross could easily pull off a Sister Abigail moniker

WWE/NXT creative officials have worked the whole Sanity storyline to perfection. While the stable may not seem just absolutely unstoppable, they have methodically honed the skills for several different new Superstars, all of which will soon be big stars on the WWE main roster. One of those Superstars I am speaking of is Nikki Cross.

Nikki is a Scottish professional wrestler who made her mark while closer to home, working for top area promotions such as Pro Wrestling: EVE and Insane Championship Wrestling. Since signing her WWE contract, Nikki has adapted wonderfully and has, in fact, turned into one of NXT's top women's contenders.

Nikki's dark demeanour and unpredictability would make her a potentially perfect talent for the role of Bray's estranged Sister Abigail.

#3 Sarah Logan (Crazy Mary)

Enter captio
She's not-so-crazy anymore

NXT is stocked full of fresh, new talent, especially when it comes to the ladies of the Yellow Brand. One of the newest and most promising talents on the NXT roster is someone who made a name for herself as "Crazy Mary." She had some great success with major independent promotions such as Shimmer, JCW, ICW and Ring of Honor, just to name a few.

Now that she is with NXT, "Crazy Mary" is no more. Instead, her new persona is laid back, compared to her crazy days. However, she has made it clear that Sarah Logan is just a name and no matter what she is announced as during her entrances to the ring, the core of who she truly is, will always be the same.

Sarah has the same mystique that we have all grown to appreciate and respect from Bray Wyatt. Partnering her with Bray could be a perfect match.

#2 Mika Rotunda

Enter c
Who needs experience when the business is in your blood?

No, this is not a mistake. Yes, Mika Rotunda is one of the absolute best possible candidates to join her real-life brother in his mission to take down the machine.

For those who are not familiar with who Mika Rotunda is, she is the real-life sister of Bray Wyatt and Bo Dallas. They are descendants of the legendary Windham/Rotunda family, which includes names such as Barry Windham, Blackjack Mulligan and of course her father, Mike Rotunda, also known as "I.R.S."

It's also worth noting that Mika is not a complete stranger to the squared-circle. She has had a couple of tryouts with WWE and she has spent a significant amount of time at the WWE Performance Center, training with the WWE/NXT training staff and coaches.

Having Mika Rotunda assume the role of Sister Abigail could be a very natural and organic move for everyone involved, which would possibly result in great on-screen storytelling.

#1 Paige

E
This would be the perfect comeback for Paige

It's no secret that Paige is now seen as the black sheep of the WWE women's division. Since her impromptu hiatus, the self-proclaimed "Anti-Diva" has been on one heck of a roller-coaster ride.

One major component to her new way of life happens to be her other half, which is Alberto El Patron. It's blatantly obvious that Paige has changed since being with her new love, but fans are still eager to see a comeback.

Of all of the names on this list, Paige is the one with the total package. Her in-ring ability, combined with her overall experience and showmanship makes her the best possible candidate to help revive the Eater of Worlds' career.

Quick Links