• Sports News
  • NFL
  • Cowboys fans sound off on Mike McCarthy being named in bottom tier in NFL HC power rankings
New York Giants v Dallas Cowboys

Cowboys fans sound off on Mike McCarthy being named in bottom tier in NFL HC power rankings

Mike McCarthy and the Dallas Cowboys have been under pressure from their own fanbase to deliver a Lombardi Trophy. McCarthy is a Super Bowl-winning coach from his time with the Green Bay Packers but doesn't seem to get the proper respect.

This was proven true as former NFL player turned analyst Ross Tucker ranked the head coach at No. 21. His ranking was not well-received by Dallas fans. They took to Twitter to share their displeasure with the ranking. Some noted that the hate towards the head coach is real:

Ad
Back to back 12-5 seasons and Mike Mccarthy ranked 21 lol the hate is real lol twitter.com/the33rdteamfb/…
.@RossTuckerNFL's full head coaching power rankings

Who should be higher or lower?
@The33rdTeamFB @RossTuckerNFL Mike McCarthy of Dallas Cowboys has the 2nd most wins in past 2 seasons (two 12 win seasons). You having him at 21 ranking disqualified your entire ranking 🤦‍♂️
Ad
Back to back 12 and 5 with a trojan horse OC, but Big Mike 21?

#Goofy twitter.com/The33rdTeamFB/…
.@RossTuckerNFL's full head coaching power rankings

Who should be higher or lower?
Mike McCarthy should not be 21. This is bs. He has back to back 12 win seasons twitter.com/The33rdTeamFB/…
.@RossTuckerNFL's full head coaching power rankings

Who should be higher or lower?
Ad

Other fans compared the head coaches ranked above McCarthy, including Nick Sirianni and Sean Payton:

Also, Nick Sirianni coached the Eagles to an 0-2 record without his starting QB, with a Super Bowl caliber roster..

Mike McCarthy coached the Cowboys to a 4-1 record without his starting QB..

Make this list make sense 🤦🏽‍♂️ twitter.com/the33rdteamfb/…
.@RossTuckerNFL's full head coaching power rankings

Who should be higher or lower?
Sean Payton:

Win-loss record: 222-161-1
Playoff record: 11-11
Super Bowl wins: 1

Mike McCarthy:

Win-loss record: 271-188-2
Playoff record: 14-15
Super Bowl wins: 1

So why is Payton ranked 4 and McCarthy ranked 21???? twitter.com/The33rdTeamFB/…
.@RossTuckerNFL's full head coaching power rankings

Who should be higher or lower?
In no world is Ron Rivera currently A better coach than Mike McCarthy twitter.com/the33rdteamfb/…
.@RossTuckerNFL's full head coaching power rankings

Who should be higher or lower?
Ad
So Mike McCarthy has a HOF resume dam near and back to back 12 win seasons and they have him at 21?? lol just comedy #cowboys twitter.com/the33rdteamfb/…
.@RossTuckerNFL's full head coaching power rankings

Who should be higher or lower?
Mike McCarthy should be ahead of Brandon Staley, Ron Rivera, and Arthur Smith. twitter.com/The33rdTeamFB/…
.@RossTuckerNFL's full head coaching power rankings

Who should be higher or lower?
Ad

Of the 20 head coaches ranked ahead of McCarthy on this list, eight of them have won at least one Super Bowl:

  • Andy Reid
  • Bill Belichick
  • Mike Tomlin
  • Sean Payton
  • Sean McVay
  • Pete Carroll
  • Doug Pederson
  • John Harbaugh

The 59-year-old head coach has led the Dallas Cowboys to the playoffs in two of his three seasons. McCarthy and Dallas made it to the NFC Divisional Round last season, but fell short against the San Francisco 49ers. Yet, Dallas' 30 total regular-season wins are tied for the fifth-most since the 2020 season.


McCarthy and the Cowboys face one of the toughest schedules this upcoming season

Dallas will have the fifth-toughest schedule this season as they look to make it back to the playoffs. They will open up the 2023 season on Sunday Night Football against their NFC East rival New York Giants on the road.

Week Five will have a playoff rematch versus the 49ers. The team face the defending NFC champion Philadelphia Eagles in Week Nine and, on Christmas Eve, the Cowboys will get the early gift of facing the Miami Dolphins.

Reaching 12 wins just as America's Team did in 2022 could prove difficult in 2023. We'll see if McCarthy can prove that his ranking was wrong this season with a deep playoff run.

Ad
Edited by
Kanav Seth
 
See more
More from Sportskeeda