Worst romantic pairings in WWE history

Edge and Lita told a great story in the ring

WWE is essentially story telling and what is a good story without a little romance?

Many WWE superstars have been paired together with Divas and some couples have made their chemistry work, taking their individual careers to new heights. Edge and Lita developed new dimensions to their characters with their on screen (and off screen) romance during the mid 2000s.

Miss Elizabeth was an integral part of Randy Savage’s character.

But there have been a lot of on-screen couples that were utter failures – This list takes a look at the top 5.


#5 Billy Gunn and Torrie Wilson

Mr and Ms Ass?

Billy Gunn has been repackaged multiple times in the WWE – be it as the Smoking Gunns, as part of the successful New Age Outlaws and DX stables, as part of the seemingly gay couple in the Billy & Chuck tandem and much more. But his partnership with Torrie Wilson was as random as it could get.

Gunn who had also been known as Mr.Ass and Torrie was scripted to have developed an infatuation for each other over the fact that both of them had impressive backsides – Yup, that happened.

Torrie was immensely popular on her own and the idiotic angle did not help her in any way – it made even little sense when the duo entered into a rivalry which later became a partnership with Nidia and Jamie Noble, with the latter also vying for Torrie’s affections.

Gunn’s career sunk like the Titanic and Torrie would eventually move on to better things.

#4 Al Wilson and Dawn Marie

Not the most diplomatic and polished of storylines to say the least

Another attempt to incorporate glamour and family drama into story lines, the Al Wilson - Dawn Marie saga had people scratching their heads.

The storyline had Dawn Marie seduce Al Wilson, the father of Torrie as a payback for losing a number of matches to the latter. Dawn then kayfabe proceeded to marry Al and the elder Wilson seemingly died during honeymoon sex.

The storyline also had Dawn forcible making Torrie strip for filming a lesbian sex tape, distorting what was primarily supposed to be a pro-wrestling centric show into one replete with sexual innuendos and unnecessary shenanigans.

#3 Sable and Vince McMahon

It’s fair to say Vince McMahon has had his pick of women over the years

Vince McMahon has had numerous affairs with WWE Divas on screen, ranging from Trish Stratus to Torrie Wilson and Stacy Keibler. But none was as awkward as Vince’s relationship with Sable.

Sable was the most popular Diva in wrestling in the late 90s and she had an acrimonious exit from the WWE, filing a sexual harassment case against her former employer. This made it weird that she would be put in a storyline as Vince McMahon’s mistress during her return to the company in 2003.

This was despite the fact that Sable was having a relationship with the then WWE Champion Brock Lesnar at the time. Whatever you say about Vince McMahon, he certainly had the grapefruits.

#2 Natalya and The Great Khali

Ya, this happened

Another case of random pairing, Natalya and the Great Khali’s on screen chemistry stuck out like a sore thumb. The daughter of Jim Neidhart was – still is – one of the greatest in-ring workers in the women’s division whereas Khali was pretty much one of the worst wrestlers to have set foot inside a WWE ring.

Khali’s initial aura had worn off and the WWE Creative created a filler role pairing the two together.

It wasn’t a success, to say the very least.

#1 John Cena and Eve

This happened too
John Cena's on-screen relationships have never had much of a success. Cena’s partnership with A J Lee was awkward at best, but it was overshadowed by his segments with Eve Torres.
A confusing segment had Internet favourite Zack Ryder finally achieve championship success and celebrate with his (kayfabe) girlfriend Eve, only to have him assaulted by Kane.
Cena tried to stand by his friend Ryder, but ended up making out with his girlfriend Eve, to end Raw.
Instead of apologising for his actions, Cena was booked to bury the trashy Eve the next night as the latter became a heel after admitting that she took advantage of Cena to get to the top.
Poor Ryder looked like a complete loser and never really regained his momentum after that storyline.

Quick Links