New User posted their first comment

Premier League 2019-20: 5 January signings who are unlikely to succeed at their new club

Tottenham's Gedson Fernandes against Watford in the Premier League.
Modified 05 Feb 2020, 08:40 IST
Top 5 / Top 10

It has been a busy winter transfer window for most of the Premier League clubs. From the traditional 'Big Six', Tottenham and Manchester United have been big spenders while Manchester City and Chelsea kept their proceedings low-key with no players coming in.

Usually, the winter transfer window is that part of the season when clubs look to bring in players rather than off-loading them, with intentions of meeting their season objectives. This window saw a rather mixed response by the clubs as few of them ended up off-loading more players than recruiting some.

With all the new talent coming in, today we take a look at the top 5 signings from this winter transfer window, who are unlikely to succeed at their new club. Without much ado, here are our top 5 picks of the day!

#5 Kyle Walker-Peters (Southampton)

Kyle Walker-Peters against Colchester United in the Carabao Cup third round.
Kyle Walker-Peters against Colchester United in the Carabao Cup third round.

After struggling for minutes at Tottenham, Kyle Walker-Peters has made a switch to Southampton on a loan deal which runs through the end of the season.

As stalwarts like Jan Vertonghen and Toby Alderweireld have been aging for quite some time now, Spurs have begun their defensive revolution way back at the beginning of the previous season when they brought in players like Serge Aurier, Juan Foyth and Davinson Sanchez.

With Southampton's Cedric Soares moving to Arsenal on loan, Walker-Peters will find it easy to break into the first team as a regular starter but he finds himself in a squad that has been exposed time and again for their defensive flaws.

Having had average performances for Spurs beside a fairly strong back-line of Vertonghen, Alderweireld and Danny Rose, Walker-Peters is not expected to be a game-changer for the struggling and unimpressive Southampton defence where the back-four is going to be under immense pressure every minute of the game.


#4 Nabil Bentaleb (Newcastle United)

Newcastle United v Norwich City - Premier League
Newcastle United v Norwich City - Premier League

Since his departure from Premier League, Nabil Bentaleb has not been one of the most consistent players around Europe. Now he finds himself under the guard of Steve Bruce at Newcastle who is vying to keep the club afloat in the Premier League table's bottom half.

The Algerian fell out of favour at his previous club Schalke, which resulted in him openly expressing his desire to move away from Germany, especially to England - a country where he has played before, in his prime.

Signed to increase the squad depth in the midfield, Bentaleb had a poor debut against Oxford United when he was chosen in place of an injured Jonjo Shelvey.

To impress the Magpies' supporters, the 25-year-old will have to outperform the likes of Shelvey, Sean Longstaff and other upcoming stars, a feat which seems highly unlikely considering Bruce's confidence in both the existing midfielders.


#3 Odion Ighalo (Manchester United)

England v Nigeria - International Friendly
England v Nigeria - International Friendly

As a replacement for injured main striker Marcus Rashford, Manchester United was tipped to go for a striker in the winter transfer window, but the high profile pursuit of Bruno Fernandes left the club with hardly enough time for any serious negotiations for the forward position.

The Red Devils eventually moved for Odion Ighalo in the wee hours of the transfer deadline day, on a loan arrangement, which seemed to be a panic buy for a club of United's stature.

The red half of Manchester has been struggling with a mini goal drought in the absence of Rashford, and this means that the club needs someone right now who can adapt immediately to the Premier League conditions and starts banging in goals right from his debut.

Ighalo has way too little time to adapt at United considering his last spell in a very different Chinese League with Shanghai Shenhua.

Though the Nigerian has Premier League experience with Watford, it is unlikely that he will succeed very soon again in England, with existing players like Anthony Martial and Mason Greenwood competing for his spot.

Also Read: Josh King frustrated over failed Old Trafford move

1 / 2 NEXT
Published 05 Feb 2020, 08:40 IST
Fetching more content...
App download animated image Get the free App now
❤ī¸ Favorites Edit