5 scariest superstars in WWE history

Every WWE Superstar has a unique character or 'gimmick' to gain popularity. Some are over-the-top, some are inspired from real-life, and some even tap into the supernatural.

The objective of a scary gimmick is to instill fear in the hearts of fans and their opponents. However, the audience feeds on this fear, adding to the intrigue of the character.

On the occasion of yesterday's Halloween, let's look at five of the scariest superstars in WWE history:

Special Mention - WWE Superstar Papa Shango

In 1992, the haunting voodoo practitioner Charles Wright, aka Papa Shango, made his shocking debut in WWE. He intimidated opponents with his morbid skeletal face paint and a necklace made from bones. His physique was also equally imposing.

Although his tenure in WWE was short, Papa Shango was famously known for his interference during the WrestleMania 8 main event match between Hulk Hogan and Sid Justice, aka Sycho Sid, resulting in a disqualification. His infamous feud with the late Ultimate Warrior often saw him cast a spell on the latter.

In a segment with the late Mean Gene Okerlund, Shango cast a spell, causing a strange dark liquid to flow from the Warrior's head as the WWE Universe looked on in complete shock. The incident, among many, has solidified his stance as one of the spookiest WWE Superstars.

#5 WWE Superstar Alexa Bliss

The transition of Alexa Bliss from the Goddess to the Supernatural gimmick has been one of the best in WWE recently. Her brief alliance with The Fiend, who was responsible for the change, was extraordinary.

In Alexa's Playground, Bliss and her creepy doll Lilly have scared the likes of Shayna Baszler, Eva Marie, and even Randy Orton. The Viper feuded with Alexa before his match against The Fiend at WrestleMania 37.

The 'Five Feet of Fury' was last seen in her supernatural gimmick against Charlotte Flair at Extreme Rules 2021. Alexa recently teased a gimmick change as the WWE Universe waits to see her return.

#4 WWE Superstar Boogeyman

The Boogeyman has been one of the scariest and creepiest characters in the WWE.

Having made his debut on the October 14, 2005, edition of Smackdown, his entrance involved crouching to the ring while eating a can of worms. He also carried a voodoo stick and an oversized alarm clock that he smashed on his head.

Superstars like John Cena and King Booker certainly felt the chills in their interactions with this hellish character, especially when he said, "I'm the Boogeyman, and I'm comin' to getcha," followed by the maniacal laughter.

#3 WWE Hall of Famer Kane

Kane has put fear in the hearts of WWE Superstars and fans alike for over two decades.

With the sinister mask or without it, Kane's extreme moments, especially setting other superstars on fire, still give us the chills. The Big Red Machine was first seen at Badd Blood: In Your House in 1997 during The Undertaker and Shawn Michaels' Hell in a Cell match.

Seeing his kayfabe half-brother, The Phenom looked petrified. Kane ripped open the cell door with ease and tombstoned Taker, costing him the match.

The WWE Hall of Famer has not looked back since, achieving insurmountable heights in this business. Despite being shunned by the audience at first, Kane became one of the most popular superstars of WWE.

#2 Former WWE Superstar 'The Fiend' Bray Wyatt

Few superstars in the history of WWE are as frightening as The Fiend. Bray Wyatt's alter ego first appeared in a WWE ring in 2019 on an episode of Monday Night RAW when he hit Sister Abigail on Finn Balor.

The Fiend's demonic mask, along with his distorted "let me in," certainly gave everyone the jitters. The 'Eater of the Worlds,' feuded with the likes of Seth Rollins, Braun Strowman, John Cena and Randy Orton. None of them could escape his wrath.

He was last seen in action at WrestleMania 37 against Randy Orton. WWE released Bray Wyatt in July this year.

#1 WWE Superstar The Undertaker

The Undertaker is undoubtedly the most frightening WWE superstar to ever enter the squared circle.

Since debuting as part of the Million Dollar Team at Survivor Series 1990, The Deadman has been striking fear in the hearts of superstars and fans for the past three decades. His manager, the late Paul Bearer, too played a huge role in his success. With his shrill voice and eerie urn, Bearer and Taker were the highlight of the company.

Not only was The Phenom scary in his demeanor, but he was also one of the most athletically-gifted wrestlers for his tall seven-foot frame. The WWE legend's WrestleMania record of 25-2 speaks volumes of his sheer grit, determination, and hard work.

One can only pay respect to The Deadman, who forced superstars to "rest in peace" through his unparalleled in-ring ability.