#2 Mandy Rose
Mandy Rose broke into the WWE during the sixth season of the competition WWE Tough Enough held in 2015. Rose shortly then made her NXT debut but was largely featured in tag team matches or battled against bigger stars in losing efforts.
Her big break came in 2017 when she joined forces with Sonya Deville and Paige as they attacked Sasha Banks, Bayley, Mickie James, and Alexa Bliss on an episode of RAW. Paige was one of the biggest Superstars in WWE at the time and the move helped bolster her two associates.
Later, an injury to Paige rendered her out of competition and forced her to retire soon after, but Rose and DeVille stayed together and continued to battle in singles and tag team action.
Rose got her biggest match yet against Asuka for the SmackDown Women’s Championship at Fastlane 2019 but lost the match.
While she and DeVille continue to battle in tag team action and have challenged for the WWE Women’s Tag Team Championships, it is surprising that Rose has been unable to hold gold in the company till now.