You may hate me for this, but the Hunter x Hunter 1999 anime is better than Madhouse's in one key area

The comparison of the 1999 and 2011 Hunter x Hunter anime adaptations stands among the most heated discussions in the anime community. Madhouse's 2011 adaptation earned legitimate acclaim for its animation quality and storytelling excellence and its accuracy to the manga, but the 1999 Nippon Animation version achieved equally significant accomplishments through its different approach.

The 1999 version showcased atmospheric darkness and tonal complexity, which created a psychologically impactful experience that effectively revealed the hidden menace in Yoshihiro Togashi's cheerful adventure storyline despite its technical imperfections.

Disclaimer: This article reflects the opinions of the writer.

---

Visual and tonal divergence in the 1999 and 2011 Hunter x Hunter adaptations

The primary distinction between these adaptations emerges from their distinct visual styles and the specific color schemes they utilize. Viewers of the 1999 adaptation recognized it as an atypical shounen story due to its muted tones and shadowy scenes that created a subdued aesthetic.

The original adaptation highlighted Hunter x Hunter's power to surprise viewers through tonal dissonance, while Madhouse's version used bright, vibrant colors to convey the excitement of Gon's adventure. The Phantom Troupe arc clearly demonstrates this difference.

In 1999, Yorknew City appeared as an urban landscape filled with genuine horror through its dim lighting and oppressive environment. The Troupe members exhibited a more authentic menacing presence because their designs highlighted their relentless killer nature instead of the sympathetic antiheroes they would later evolve into, according to fan perception.

The artistic approach strengthened the story's main conflict between youthful curiosity and adult savagery. The philosophical design approach for characters intensified their dark portrayal. While Gon kept his positive personality in the 1999 adaptation, viewers could always see signs of hidden darkness beneath his innocent appearance.

The deliberate use of shadows on characters' faces during uncertain scenes and intentional negative space to evoke discomfort showcased advanced visual storytelling techniques that matched Togashi's complex narrative style. The 1999 adaptation paced its narrative to deepen the psychological examination of its characters' ethical complexity.

The original anime had the freedom to dwell on difficult scenes, which let the violent actions and moral challenges resonate more deeply with the audience. The adaptation format enabled the story themes of moral relativism and the loss of innocence to grow naturally without constraints. The dark atmosphere developed significantly through the work of the soundtrack and audio design.

Additionally, the 2011 series featured uplifting orchestral compositions that highlighted adventure and friendships, while the 1999 version chose experimental music that left viewers feeling unsettled. The auditory environment worked hand in hand with the visual darkness to produce an integrated aesthetic experience that strengthened the series' complex themes.

Some critics point out that the darker tone led to a loss of the manga's tonal variety, and that Madhouse's adaptation delivered a true-to-vision result according to Togashi's original concept. However, the 1999 adaptation of Hunter x Hunter created a distinctive viewing experience by focusing on psychological horror elements, which offered its own artistic validity despite differing from the source material.

---

Conclusion

The 1999 Hunter x Hunter adaptation demonstrates how artistic vision can surpass technical polish to create an atmospheric masterpiece. It stands out for its ability to deliver a complex psychological experience through its dark visual style, which echoes the series' themes more profoundly than brighter mainstream adaptations ever could.

The 1999 anime also demonstrates an exceptional understanding of how shadows can expose hidden truths that bright light tends to conceal, outperforming any previous or subsequent adaptations in this regard.

---