The Twisted Tale of Amanda Knox episode 3 ending explained: How did the false narrative destroy Amanda?

The Guardian of Perugia, The Twisted Tale of Amanda Knox episode 3, was released on August 27, 2025, on Hulu. The series shows the worst turn yet in Amanda's story of being wrongfully convicted. At the end of the episode, the media steals her private journals, leaks them, and uses them as weapons against her. They call her "Foxy Knoxy," a s*x-crazed villain instead of a sad friend. The ending shows that Amanda's fate was sealed not by forensic evidence, but by a made-up story that got a lot of media attention and played on people's biases.

Disclaimer: The following article contains spoilers from The Twisted Tale of Amanda Knox. Reader’s discretion is required.

Episode 3 is about Knox's first few days in Cappane Prison. She has to go through humiliating strip searches, manipulative interrogations, and even a fake HIV diagnosis that is meant to break her mentally. Her stolen writings fuel the public’s appetite for scandal, turning her into an object of hatred.

The Twisted Tale of Amanda Knox episode 3 ending: How did Amanda’s stolen journals turn into the “Foxy Knoxy” narrative?

A still from The Twisted Tale of Amanda Knox (Image via Hulu)

The ending of The Twisted Tale of Amanda Knox episode 3 is a haunting portrait of character assassination. Amanda's journals were stolen after she was tricked into writing down the names of her past s*xual partners by a fake HIV diagnosis. When she finally turns on the TV in prison, her private writings are shown as proof that she has been seeing other men.

The media in Italy and around the world use her MySpace posts, photos, and diary entries to call her "Foxy Knoxy" and the "American witch."

However, forensic reports reveal a twist: the bloody fingerprints found in Meredith's room do not match Amanda or any of the other people who are being accused. This should have been a big step forward, but it isn't.

Why was Amanda Knox’s prison life so dehumanizing?

Amanda is confused and embarrassed when she first gets to Cappane Prison. At first, she thinks she might be in witness protection because she is being searched without clothes on and looked at closely for a bruise on her neck. Even though her naivety makes her seem innocent, the prosecutors see it as a sign that she is lying.

Warden Banti makes her pain worse. His rude questions and treatment are not about justice; they are meant to be tricky. People don't treat Amanda like a suspect; instead, they treat her like prey in a system that wants to break her.

Even times of comfort are turned into weapons. The moment Amanda sees her mother Edda again is secretly recorded. When Amanda tells her mother that the police had to apologize. The police see this as proof that Amanda is cocky. What should have been proof of her sadness turns out to be more evidence against her.

This environment makes it hard to stay alive. In episode 3, Amanda loses her freedom, her humanity, and sense of self-worth while she is in jail.

What was Giuliano Mignini’s role in shaping the narrative?

A lot of time is spent on prosecutor Giuliano Mignini in this episode, showing how his views affected Amanda's life. Being raised in a strict and religious family and being affected by the Monster of Florence murders made Mignini crazy about the idea of evil done in a ritualistic way. He thought that women could make men bad, and he saw s*x as a way for sin to spread.

Mignini didn't have any evidence when Meredith's case came across his desk, but he did have some ideas. He made up a story about Amanda being the center of a s*x game that went badly. He believed this theory because it fit his fears and beliefs, even though it didn't match the evidence.

By the end of episode 3, it is evident that Mignini wasn't prosecuting based on facts. He was making up a villain, and Amanda matched his biases, which made her an easy person to blame for a crime she didn't commit.

How did the false HIV report break Amanda further?

The fabricated HIV report made the third episode the cruellest one. Amanda is told she tested positive, a lie designed to force her into listing her past s*xual partners. She writes them down in her journals, believing it’s necessary to protect others.

When her journals are stolen and made public, the list is used to make her look bad in public. The news turns her private life into evidence of wrongdoing, giving her the name "Foxy Knoxy," which will follow her around for years.

The most private breach was the false HIV report, which used Amanda's private information as public ammunition. It shows that the government was ready to use psychological torture instead of the truth to get someone convicted.

How did the hearing and media frenzy seal Amanda’s fate?

Amanda's lawyers want her to be locked up at home, but Giuliano Mignini says she is too dangerous and will probably run away. His arguments are not based on facts, but on a story he made up about a s*x game. Amanda will likely stay in jail for years because her request was turned down.

The media affects how people around the world think and feel. Journalists use stolen journals, photos, and blog posts to make up a scandalous story about Amanda's life. The public no longer sees a scared 20-year-old student, but rather a con artist.

For Amanda, this is the moment when someone steals her identity. "Foxy Knoxy," a stereotype made up by prosecutors and pushed by reporters, casts a shadow over the real Amanda Knox.

What do the bloody fingerprints reveal about the case?

At the end of the episode, it is revealed that the bloody prints discovered in Meredith Kercher's room do not belong to Amanda, Raffaele, or Patrick Lumumba. This detail makes the whole prosecution story less credible. If Amanda planned the crime, why would there be signs that someone else was there?

This twist shows the audience how clearly evidence and story are at odds with each other. Fingerprints should have changed the case, but the "Foxy Knoxy" scandal made them less important.

The Twisted Tale of Amanda Knox episode 3 is available to stream on Hulu.

About the author

Rajan is an Entertainment Writer at Sportskeeda with previous experience of 6 years in writing about the genre. While he has a Bachelor's degree in Computer Application, it was his passion for the domain that led him to pursue a career in the field. He firmly believes that research is key when reporting on any topic, and glances through a wide array of articles to produce informative and accurate content.

Rajan admires Robert Downey Jr., Bob Dylan, and John Mayer since he feels they are the best at their trade. He is passionate about music and has had the opportunity to interact with popular Bollywood music directors A. R. Rahman, Pritam and Vishal-Sekhar.

If he could go back in time, he would jump at the opportunity to be part of Coldplay's hit track, 'A Sky Full of Stars.'

Know More

Edited by Niharika Dabral